UPDATED <> NSR <> New Sig <> 3 Versions

Swindler · Post by **Swindler** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 2:02 am

v.1

v.2

v.3

v.4 (Something like that dom?)

C'n'C Ty

Luoma · Post by **Luoma** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 2:51 am

I like that you eased up on the 'busyness of your work

But now its almost abit too simple ^^

v.1 is best imo

aazumak · Post by **aazumak** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 2:53 am

1 has good color, but the render is just chillin there, it doesn't blend in with the background at all

2 i don't like it at all, im sorry, the solid blue color doesn't look to good, and I've always been against a single color for a sig(other than the occasional black and white)

3 its better than the 1st one in the aspect that the render fits better into the background, since it is only shades of gray it fits together nicely

so it flows so much better than #1, but it is colorless and unless the sig is friggin amazing, colorless doesnt usually look better

you made a nice background adn it has a focal point!!!!! good for you on that aspect, it looks so much better b/c of the focal point. next i would just work on blending the sig into the background more and making the sigs colors match

Swindler · Post by **Swindler** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 2:54 am

Luoma wrote:I like that you eased up on the 'busyness of your work But now its almost abit too simple ^^

v.1 is best imo

haha ty

yeah i tried to cut it down with the c4ds and sh1t, but maybe to much^^. <3

Swindler · Post by **Swindler** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 3:01 am

aazumak wrote:

3 its better than the 1st one in the aspect that the render fits better into the background, since it is only shades of gray it fits together nicely

so it flows so much better than #1, but it is colorless and unless the sig is friggin amazing, colorless doesnt usually look better

you made a nice background adn it has a focal point!!!!! good for you on that aspect, it looks so much better b/c of the focal point. next i would just work on blending the sig into the background more and making the sigs colors match

Yeah i was thinking that the grey/white one was better then the first to.. But ty for the comment <3

HOLLAstir · Post by **HOLLAstir** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 3:37 am

aazumak wrote:but it is colorless and unless the sig is friggin amazing, colorless doesnt usually look better

Eh, i'd have to disagree, I don't think color'd sigs are "usually" better then black and white. It's all about execution and how well does it fit. Anyways, what a difference taking your ritalin makes hejsan. I can actually see a flow in this one. You just need depth too it. I like v3 the most. I don't like where you placed the text though. Like aazumy said, just need to work on blending in your render into the sig now, and creating that depth <3

Swindler · Post by **Swindler** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 3:58 am

Ty HOLLAstir <3 Well I was to clumpsy to forget to save a .psd file -.- typical. Maybe gonna try to make a new one tomorrow and see if i can make some blending and depth in it <3

Aiyas · Post by **Aiyas** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 4:45 am

I definitely like how you did the background.

I like the colors in version 1, but I agree with what someone said in that the render just kinda lies there. I like how it looks in gray(version 3). Version 2 just doesn't do anything for me, at all.

So, I guess I'm torn between versions 1 and 3, leaning towards version 3.

Faiien · Post by **Faiien** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 5:09 am

nice

Post by **dom** » Sat Jan 05, 2008 5:17 am

Take the colour one, put the black and white layer ontop of it, erase all off that layer that is ontop of the character - leave the background black and white.

Fine tune the hues to get something that flows.