Lucky Attribute Vs Lucky Powder ??

Sunaj · Post by **Sunaj** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 12:31 pm

Ok I dont have any time to be searching these forums for this question, so SUE ME

Is the lucky attribute on equipment any luckier than using the lucky powders?

I tried to get my +4 SOS Moon Bow to +5 wasting like 10 astrals so far all using lucky powders. And obviouly all failed since my bow is still +4.

So...some guild mates told me to use a lucky stone....which costs like 6m-7m... I'm not gonna be buying that..

So is Lucky attribute luckier than Lucky powder?

Chaby · Post by **Chaby** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 12:35 pm

No. Use both.

Fat_Smurf · Post by **Fat_Smurf** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 12:48 pm

how do you loose lucky charge? I've done alchemy on my shield with 6 lucky and now it's 4 dunno why it drop (well it have to drop one day, but what make it drop?)

Sharp324 · Post by **Sharp324** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 12:51 pm

Fat_Smurf wrote:how do you loose lucky charge? I've done alchemy on my shield with 6 lucky and now it's 4 dunno why it drop (well it have to drop one day, but what make it drop?)

i think it uses a lucky everytime or almost everytime you try to add a attribute?

StaticX · Post by **StaticX** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:16 pm

Sharp324 wrote:
Fat_Smurf wrote:how do you loose lucky charge? I've done alchemy on my shield with 6 lucky and now it's 4 dunno why it drop (well it have to drop one day, but what make it drop?)

i think it uses a lucky everytime or almost everytime you try to add a attribute?

Every + = Poof 1 lucky down :twisted:

Fat_Smurf · Post by **Fat_Smurf** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:36 pm

Sperm wrote:
Sharp324 wrote:
Fat_Smurf wrote:how do you loose lucky charge? I've done alchemy on my shield with 6 lucky and now it's 4 dunno why it drop (well it have to drop one day, but what make it drop?)

i think it uses a lucky everytime or almost everytime you try to add a attribute?

Every + = Poof 1 lucky down

ur sure? cause i've + my shield to +3 and I'm pretty sure it was 6 lucky not 4 before :S

juntakashi · Post by **juntakashi** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:41 pm

ur sure? cause i've + my shield to +3 and I'm pretty sure it was 6 lucky not 4 before :S

yes.. 1 charge gone when u do 1 time alchemy (+)

Waisha · Post by **Waisha** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:42 pm

dumbest topic ever. its like: shield vs sword?

USE BOTH :banghead:

Fat_Smurf · Post by **Fat_Smurf** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:45 pm

juntakashi wrote:
ur sure? cause i've + my shield to +3 and I'm pretty sure it was 6 lucky not 4 before :S

yes.. 1 charge gone when u do 1 time alchemy (+)

muh it might be 7 lucky then :S

juntakashi · Post by **juntakashi** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:46 pm

dumbest topic ever. its like: shield vs sword?

nah...both powder and attribute has lucky effect

u can attack wif a sword but u cant attack wif a shield

see the diff? :shock:

underK · Post by **underK** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 1:55 pm

Fat_Smurf wrote:
juntakashi wrote:
ur sure? cause i've + my shield to +3 and I'm pretty sure it was 6 lucky not 4 before :S

yes.. 1 charge gone when u do 1 time alchemy (+)

muh it might be 7 lucky then :S

well u lose lucky attribute when the alchemy want to fail or it fails. maybe it wanted to fail to +2 and to +3, but lucky attribute helped u... but it desappears then, so u lost 2 lucky.

StealMySoda · Post by **StealMySoda** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 2:08 pm

I believe lucky stone to be like 2 tries.
First time if it +ing succesfully it doesnt use lucky times
Second time if it +es it uses luck. Or if it fails completley one lucky times is removed

The lucky times doesnt mean, 6times will make it 6x as lucky.

Hope that cleared things up.

Which is why, u still have lucky 4.
from +0 to +1 it worked firs tiem, +1 - +2 and +2 - +3 it worked the second time around, so used 2 lucky times.

EllisD · Post by **EllisD** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 7:03 pm

StealMySoda wrote:I believe lucky stone to be like 2 tries.
First time if it +ing succesfully it doesnt use lucky times
Second time if it +es it uses luck. Or if it fails completley one lucky times is removed

The lucky times doesnt mean, 6times will make it 6x as lucky.

Hope that cleared things up.

Which is why, u still have lucky 4.
from +0 to +1 it worked firs tiem, +1 - +2 and +2 - +3 it worked the second time around, so used 2 lucky times.

+1

Found a 72 spear with lucky 6. +4'd it and still had lucky 3 on it.

Also, you cant have more than 6 of those special attributes (astral, immortal, lucky, steady) Im basing this off the fact that i get soooooo many steady stones from breaking weapons, that i tried it. Cannot exceed 6.

HBblade · Post by **HBblade** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 7:41 pm

having lucky attribute + lucky powder means that it'll go through both lucky to get you to succeed in alchemizing double wat little luck you have...so u can succeed and lose lucky attribute, succeed & not lose it, fail & lose it

Waisha · Post by **Waisha** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 7:47 pm

juntakashi wrote:
dumbest topic ever. its like: shield vs sword?

nah...both powder and attribute has lucky effect

u can attack wif a sword but u cant attack wif a shield

see the diff?

no.

2 good things. why not use both?

im not wif u.

Post by **Rainigul** » Wed Apr 25, 2007 10:09 pm

This is how lucky works:

You try to make your weapon +1, it works, and you're lucky remains, let's say 6.

You try to make your weapon +2 and it works, lucky remains 6.

Now, you try to make it +3, but (you don't see this part) the alchemy fails, then you lose one lucky, and it tries the alchemy again. Success.

You try to make it +4, but it fails, used lucky, but fails yet again.

Now you're back where you started

Fat_Smurf · Post by **Fat_Smurf** » Thu Apr 26, 2007 12:23 am

Rainigul wrote:This is how lucky works:

You try to make your weapon +1, it works, and you're lucky remains, let's say 6.

You try to make your weapon +2 and it works, lucky remains 6.

Now, you try to make it +3, but (you don't see this part) the alchemy fails, then you lose one lucky, and it tries the alchemy again. Success.

You try to make it +4, but it fails, used lucky, but fails yet again.

Now you're back where you started

make sense, so if I use powder and lucky stone it'll make 3 roll?