Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Anything else. Post a funny site or tell us about yourself. Discuss current events or whatever else you want. Post off topic threads here.
Post Reply
User avatar
woutR
Elite Member
Posts: 5573
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 5:20 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Netherlands
Contact:

Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by woutR »

http://stream.aljazeera.com/story/201212182323-0022443

In the Netherlands we have a tradition called Sinterklaas. You could almost say he's the Dutch equivalent of Santa Clause. He gives the kids presents if they were good and will give them salt and a spanking if they're bad. Sinterklaas isn't alone, he has tons of helpers. These helpers are called 'Zwarte Piet' (Black Pete) and are dressed up in a servant's costume, paint their faces black and wear black, curly wigs.
Many people that didn't grow up with this tradition are now claiming it to be racist. It's a white man and he has black people as servants, this is what bothers people and makes them say it's racist. What do you guys think?
The link I posted contains a video having exactly this debate. Is Zwarte Piet racist or not?

Spoiler!


For me, Zwarte Piet is not racist at all. I grew up with him and never once thought that it had any relation to racism or colonialism. I always presumed that Zwarte Piet was black because he climbed in and out through chimneys all day to deliver presents, and accumulated a lot of soot on his face/body. I am almost offended that people would claim it's racism. I get where they're coming from, but Sinterklaas is only perceived to be racist because he has black helpers. Sinterklaas doesn't teach any wrong values and never talks down to his helpers but is always kind. To see Sinterklaas as racist is, to me, just trying to find something racist to bitch about. I'll just say it: I think it's racist to think Sinterklaas is racist. This sounds weird, but what I mean is that in order to find Sinterklaas racist you have to believe that by definition it's racist to have a black helper when you're white. I think it's racist to believe that just because a white person leads black people he is abusing them. White people and our culture are made out to be the bad guys just because people have this racist idea that when a white man has black helpers it has to be racist and bad.
Image

<< :giveup:>>

User avatar
omier
Elite Member
Posts: 5985
Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2006 9:33 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: ...

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by omier »

That's definitely not racist. But what bothers me is that he looks like the pope(minus the beard).
Image Image Image

User avatar
Love
Elite Member
Posts: 5330
Joined: Thu Nov 08, 2007 4:29 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: guildwars2

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Love »

Is not like the media constantly brings up nonsense.
Image

Guild Wars 2, Isle of Janthir (NA)

Peace is a lie, there is only passion. Through passion, I gain strength. Through strength, I gain power. Through power, I gain victory. Through victory, my chains are broken.

User avatar
Squirt
Forum God
Posts: 8186
Joined: Sat Jan 05, 2008 9:48 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Off Topic

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Squirt »

Thought this was your santa?
Spoiler!


The dude who looks like a high level elf mage or something.
Image
Spoiler!

woutR wrote:Squirt, you're a genius when it comes to raping women.

User avatar
heroo
Forum Legend
Posts: 6618
Joined: Sat Sep 30, 2006 12:56 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Off Topic

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by heroo »

what retard thinks Zwarte Piet is racist? It's a tradition for children and it has nothing to do with racism or history. If you can not make the difference between this cheerful tradition and history, you need to grow up. I feel like people are getting more stupid every day. They don't care for the real problems and keep coming up with this kind of nonsense.
''When I die, make sure they bury me upside down, so that the world can kiss my ass.''

User avatar
cbkilla
Frequent Member
Posts: 1124
Joined: Thu Feb 11, 2010 7:17 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Azteca

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by cbkilla »

Dunno if its racist or not since im to lazy to look into the history of the holiday and see if it has anything to do with racism buuuut it does "seem" racist, which only makes it funnier L0L. Everyones to butthurt about stereotypes and "racist jokes" these days, everyone needs to smoke a bowl, laugh at each other, laugh at their selves and smoke more bowls.
Image

Image

User avatar
*BlackFox
Forum Legend
Posts: 7921
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2008 12:55 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Off Topic

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by *BlackFox »

Nah, It's not racist.
Image

User avatar
MrTwilliger
Frequent Member
Posts: 1374
Joined: Fri May 16, 2008 8:27 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Hiding

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by MrTwilliger »

I think it's racist that people get offended over the servants being black, but if the servants were white no one would say it's racist for oppressing white people. I demand equal opportunities for racism against white people!!!!!

User avatar
CrimsonNuker
Dom's Slut
Posts: 13791
Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2006 3:31 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: guildwars2

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by CrimsonNuker »

Nordinglish is always funny
ImageImageImage

User avatar
DarkBandit
Active Member
Posts: 543
Joined: Fri Mar 28, 2008 2:11 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: london, united kingdom

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by DarkBandit »

Squirt wrote:Thought this was your santa?
Spoiler!


The dude who looks like a high level elf mage or something.


LOL
The friends which were, are not the same friends which are now or the friends that will be

User avatar
Ger_slayer
Valued Member
Posts: 405
Joined: Wed Feb 27, 2008 3:27 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: High :)

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Ger_slayer »

cbkilla wrote:Dunno if its racist or not since im to lazy to look into the history of the holiday and see if it has anything to do with racism buuuut it does "seem" racist, which only makes it funnier L0L. Everyones to butthurt about stereotypes and "racist jokes" these days, everyone needs to smoke a bowl, laugh at each other, laugh at their selves and smoke more bowls.

That!
Image

Chars i have: SJSRO: NukerLover lvl 94 Inactive
ZSZC Water: NukerLover: lvl 61 Inactive
ESRO: RougeLover lvl 72: Dead
BloodySRO: Cpt_Crucnh 84: Active :D

User avatar
Razorhead
Active Member
Posts: 820
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2008 9:19 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: leagueoflegends

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Razorhead »

important fact u didn't mention:
The helpers aren't even really black!
they are only black cuz of the coal residu that gets stuck on them from going down the chimney

I said it before & i'll say it again:
The "racism card" is being played waaaaay too much

Just recently some black guy tried to ban a TinTin comic (Tintin in congo), because he found it racist...
the people in congo were displayed as "slaves"...
The book is from in the 30's; when Congo was still a "part" of belgium and people used them as slaves. So it only depicts the situation at the time

It's like saying the coloseum is racist because christians were fed to the lions there...

These "I find this racist" people are really starting to annoy me

User avatar
omier
Elite Member
Posts: 5985
Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2006 9:33 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: ...

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by omier »

1:48
Image Image Image

User avatar
woutR
Elite Member
Posts: 5573
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 5:20 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by woutR »

Razorhead wrote:important fact u didn't mention:
The helpers aren't even really black!
they are only black cuz of the coal residu that gets stuck on them from going down the chimney


woutR wrote:I always presumed that Zwarte Piet was black because he climbed in and out through chimneys all day to deliver presents, and accumulated a lot of soot on his face/body.


Ik heb het ook moeten Googlen, maar roet is kennelijk 'soot'.
Image

<< :giveup:>>

User avatar
Razorhead
Active Member
Posts: 820
Joined: Tue Apr 22, 2008 9:19 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: leagueoflegends

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Razorhead »

woutR wrote:
Razorhead wrote:important fact u didn't mention:
The helpers aren't even really black!
they are only black cuz of the coal residu that gets stuck on them from going down the chimney


woutR wrote:I always presumed that Zwarte Piet was black because he climbed in and out through chimneys all day to deliver presents, and accumulated a lot of soot on his face/body.


Ik heb het ook moeten Googlen, maar roet is kennelijk 'soot'.

my bad :P

User avatar
Swindler
Forum God
Posts: 11256
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:49 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Pimpas Paradise.

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Swindler »

No it's not racist, just the same way gingerbreads aren't racism. Serval schools banned them in Sweden just because they were black, more correctly brown and it could be insulting to foreigners. This is getting out of hand really.

User avatar
woutR
Elite Member
Posts: 5573
Joined: Wed Feb 08, 2006 5:20 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Netherlands
Contact:

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by woutR »

Swindler wrote:No it's not racist, just the same way gingerbreads aren't racism. Serval schools banned them in Sweden just because they were black, more correctly brown and it could be insulting to foreigners. This is getting out of hand really.


lold
Image

<< :giveup:>>

User avatar
TheDrop
Forum Legend
Posts: 7150
Joined: Wed May 07, 2008 1:37 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: uefa2012

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by TheDrop »

Well from the little amount of history you put and as a outsider it does seem to have racial undertones based on imperialism/colonialism..
Then again even the usual Santa Claus & elves, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, lord of the rings, etc seem to have racist undertones. This one just seems to be more obvious.

I remember cases of black soccer players in Russia, Spain, Italy etc being called monkey and having thrown bananas at them during matches..so thats obviously a bigger problem than some christmas gig
let it gooooo let it gooooOoOooOOOOOO

Let her suck my pistol
She open up her mouth and then I blow her brains out
Image

User avatar
CrimsonNuker
Dom's Slut
Posts: 13791
Joined: Sun Aug 06, 2006 3:31 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: guildwars2

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by CrimsonNuker »

Germany's Belschnickel also has a Zwarte Piet :giveup:

This episode was epic btw.
Sinterklass is still the best looking Santa Claus though.
ImageImageImage

User avatar
.curve
Elite Member
Posts: 5167
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2008 9:59 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Antelope Valley, CA

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by .curve »

cbkilla wrote:Dunno if its racist or not since im to lazy to look into the history of the holiday and see if it has anything to do with racism buuuut it does "seem" racist, which only makes it funnier L0L. Everyones to butthurt about stereotypes and "racist jokes" these days, everyone needs to smoke a bowl, laugh at each other, laugh at their selves and smoke more bowls.


This. Completely this.
Speak the truth, even if your voice shakes.
Image

User avatar
*BlackFox
Forum Legend
Posts: 7921
Joined: Wed Sep 03, 2008 12:55 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Off Topic

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by *BlackFox »

Seriously! Why do some people always "blame" racism on everything?
It's getting ridiculous!
Image

User avatar
Bartic
Frequent Member
Posts: 1284
Joined: Sat Sep 01, 2012 10:45 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: SuddenDeath

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Bartic »

*BlackFox wrote:Seriously! Why do some people always "blame" racism on everything?
It's getting ridiculous!


Only black guys do it.
Image
[SuddenDeath*PlsMeRectal]
TickleMeAnal

Image


Spoiler!

User avatar
omier
Elite Member
Posts: 5985
Joined: Thu Aug 24, 2006 9:33 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: ...

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by omier »

^Not only guys. :)
Image Image Image

User avatar
Swindler
Forum God
Posts: 11256
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:49 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Pimpas Paradise.

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Swindler »

Actually, it's more white people who believes it's racism. Most black most likely dont give a fuck.

User avatar
.curve
Elite Member
Posts: 5167
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2008 9:59 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Antelope Valley, CA

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by .curve »

Swindler wrote:Actually, it's more white people who believes it's racism. Most black most likely dont give a fuck.


I disagree. The NAACP bitching about everything is proof enough.
Speak the truth, even if your voice shakes.
Image

User avatar
Swindler
Forum God
Posts: 11256
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:49 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Pimpas Paradise.

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Swindler »

In the US maybe, cant speak for you guys over there. In Sweden most dont seem to give a shit. Btw. who's the chick in your avatar? :sohappy:

User avatar
.curve
Elite Member
Posts: 5167
Joined: Sun Dec 28, 2008 9:59 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Antelope Valley, CA

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by .curve »

Swindler wrote:In the US maybe, cant speak for you guys over there. In Sweden most dont seem to give a shit. Btw. who's the chick in your avatar? :sohappy:


Taylor Swift, but you can't have her, she's my angel.
Speak the truth, even if your voice shakes.
Image

User avatar
Swindler
Forum God
Posts: 11256
Joined: Tue Apr 10, 2007 7:49 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Pimpas Paradise.

Re: Would you consider 'Zwarte Piet' to be racist?

Post by Swindler »

Image

Post Reply

Return to “Off Topic Lounge”