Differnece between garm and prot

A place for general discussion about Silkroad Online. Talk about the game or ask questions. Please keep threads Silkroad Online related.
Post Reply
User avatar
ClairePinnholey
Hi, I'm New Here
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 4:23 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Gaia

Differnece between garm and prot

Post by ClairePinnholey »

So..I recently traded my nova prot set for a nova garm set....i gained around 800~900 more mag def and only lost around ~150 phy def....so..why do people say prot is better :|? and the parry....oh god it went from 300-400 me-> pure int s/s nuker
Last edited by ClairePinnholey on Sun Jan 30, 2011 1:11 am, edited 1 time in total.

User avatar
BuDo
Senior Member
Posts: 4714
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2008 6:16 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Xian

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by BuDo »

You're build determines whats better to wear....For example a full str player has lots of phy defense and low mag defense so it makes sense for full str players to gain some magic defense by going garment..
Image

_________________________________________________
BOW Full STR Fire level 102 -- ON A LONG BREAK..POSSIBLY FOREVER

User avatar
Amarisa
Senior Member
Posts: 4049
Joined: Sun Feb 03, 2008 12:40 am
Location: Magic

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by Amarisa »

Because if you haven't noticed. Mag damage is a lot higher then Phy damage. so that 150 Phy def you lost is just as much protection as that 600 mag def you gained.
Image

User avatar
TillTheEnd
Valued Member
Posts: 458
Joined: Sat Apr 04, 2009 3:21 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Valhalla

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by TillTheEnd »

150 is significant, but u should pay more attention to the phy/mag. reinforce of sets, it is more important than ur 'raw' phy/mag def.
trust me u lost a LOT more then just 150 phy def. ask some1 else to explain u the dmg. formula.
Are you so foolish as to not realize your own impotence? -Freya.
This ritual demands a sacrifice, and I can think of none more enticing than you...,Repent, for death is upon you -Arch Demon.

User avatar
Fiction
Advanced Member
Posts: 2147
Joined: Sun Mar 23, 2008 11:49 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Dead.(No Longer With Us)

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by Fiction »

TillTheEnd wrote:150 is significant, but u should pay more attention to the phy/mag. reinforce of sets, it is more important than ur 'raw' phy/mag def.
trust me u lost a LOT more then just 150 phy def. ask some1 else to explain u the dmg. formula.


Pretty sure that the reinforce gets added into that "raw" number you see in the stat menu.(I figured he was using that number, and not adding the def from each item himself)

Didn't this question get answered back in 06? and a million times since?
Image

User avatar
ClairePinnholey
Hi, I'm New Here
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 4:23 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Gaia

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by ClairePinnholey »

Image

User avatar
wilobix
Common Member
Posts: 195
Joined: Tue May 22, 2007 4:20 am
Quick Reply: Yes

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by wilobix »

Fiction wrote:
TillTheEnd wrote:150 is significant, but u should pay more attention to the phy/mag. reinforce of sets, it is more important than ur 'raw' phy/mag def.
trust me u lost a LOT more then just 150 phy def. ask some1 else to explain u the dmg. formula.


Pretty sure that the reinforce gets added into that "raw" number you see in the stat menu.(I figured he was using that number, and not adding the def from each item himself)

Didn't this question get answered back in 06? and a million times since?


This.
Salvation -> Shy -> Full Int Warlock/Cleric (Lvl 70)

User avatar
Tasdik
Forum God
Posts: 13202
Joined: Tue Jan 30, 2007 7:34 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Life

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by Tasdik »

ClairePinnholey

o_O

User avatar
ClairePinnholey
Hi, I'm New Here
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 4:23 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Gaia

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by ClairePinnholey »

Lies.

User avatar
ClairePinnholey
Hi, I'm New Here
Posts: 23
Joined: Sat Jan 08, 2011 4:23 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Gaia

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by ClairePinnholey »

Tasdik wrote:ClairePinnholey

o_O

Edit:
Oops..my bad DP. >_>

User avatar
McLovin1t
Loyal Member
Posts: 1825
Joined: Wed Apr 23, 2008 4:00 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Off Topic

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by McLovin1t »

Tasdik wrote:ClairePinnholey

o_O

:palm:
Image

ZSZC Water - Pure Int S/S 3x
ZSZC Fire - Pure Str Bow 4x
ZSZC Fire - Pure Int Spear 4x

User avatar
The Invisible
Addicted Member
Posts: 2626
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2011 1:28 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Home ._.

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by The Invisible »

TillTheEnd wrote:150 is significant, but u should pay more attention to the phy/mag. reinforce of sets, it is more important than ur 'raw' phy/mag def.
trust me u lost a LOT more then just 150 phy def. ask some1 else to explain u the dmg. formula.

Here is the Formula ( btw i didn't write it , i googled it ( found it at elite pvpers )) .

Physical & Magical Reinforcement.

Here goes again;
There's still a lot of people who probably don't know what the Physical/Magical Reinforce is actually for. I've been around a few forums, and none really do explain what it does (Or their just wrong with their explanations). So I've written a little bit of my knowledge down for you guys.

So lets get started!
There are a few simple calculations every serious SRO player should know.

Physical Defense= Str x Physical reinforce + Total Physical defense.
Magical Defense= Int x Physical reinforce + Total Physical defense.

Physical Attack= Str x Physical reinforce + Physical damage.
Magical Attack = Int x Magical reinforce + Magical damage.

The Reinforcement on your Weapon and your Gear is actually more important than the Physical/Magical Attack/Defense. The reason is simple; their base values in the equations listed above.
Obviously you would rather have a higher multiplier than a number you add to the equation.

Here's an example;
Lets say you have a level 100 Char, with 500 Str.

A 2-Handed Sword +5 level 98 with a Physical Attack of 2146 ~ 2558 (80%) and a Physical reinforce of 276.8% ~ 338.3% (0%)
Physical Attack= 500 x 276.8% + 2146 = 3530 ( Minimum attack power )
Physical Attack= 500 x 338.3% + 2558 = 4249.5 ( Maximum attack power )

Now the same +5 2-Handed Sword, but with 0% Physical Attack and 80% Physical reinforce

A 2-Handed Sword +5 level 98 with a Physical Attack of 2062 ~ 2454 (0%) and a Physical reinforce of 299.9% ~ 366.6% (80%)
Physical Attack=500 x 299.9% + 2062 = 3561.5 ( Minimum attack power )
Physical Attack=500 x 366.6% + 2454 = 4287 (Maximum attack power )

I know the difference isn't big, but I'm only stressing the fact that the Physical reinforce is also a very important thing you should worry about.

Here's a 2-Handed Sword +5 level 98 with 80%/80%
Physical Attack=500 x 299.9% + 2146 = 3645.5 ( Minimum attack power )
Physical Attack=500 x 366.6% + 2558 = 4391 (Maximum attack power )

Another few common question that people have:

Quote:
"What does Parry ratio do?"
Parry Ratio determines the amount of damage you receive during an attack. The higher the parry ratio, the less chance of taking maximum hit rating from an opponent.

Quote:
"What does Attack Rate do?"
Attack Rate determines the amount of damage you deal during an attack. The higher the Attack Rate, the higher the chance of dealing maximum damage to an opponent.
So in the first week in college i went with jeans and the pajama's shirt. Didn't notice what i was wearing till after i returned home.

User avatar
aishsharma
Frequent Member
Posts: 1301
Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 3:58 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: SilkroadSalvation
Contact:

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by aishsharma »

Tasdik wrote:ClairePinnholey

o_O

u notice this now? lol

I have a feeling i know who the remake is for too :wink:

OT:
what was the point of that pic anyway? iirc the effect of reinforce values are not shown in the def u see in char window.

Ofc i could be wrong...
Spoiler!

Theseus - lvl 5x - warrior/rogue

User avatar
NuclearSilo
Forum God
Posts: 8834
Joined: Mon Aug 21, 2006 12:00 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Age of Wushu

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by NuclearSilo »

On the char window, only the magical attack is not added with the reinforce.
Other numbers are ready to use in a damage formula
Playing Age of Wushu, dota IMBA

User avatar
Goseki
Veteran Member
Posts: 3452
Joined: Mon Apr 07, 2008 2:45 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Alps

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by Goseki »

Amarisa wrote:Because if you haven't noticed. Mag damage is a lot higher then Phy damage. so that 150 Phy def you lost is just as much protection as that 600 mag def you gained.


This too. A lot of ppl forget that magical attacks have a higher base value anyways.
.curve wrote:Unless Silkroad has a hole I can stick it in, I prefer spending money on the girlfriend.

Image
Image
Spoiler!

User avatar
lotri
Regular Member
Posts: 251
Joined: Sun Jul 15, 2007 9:26 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: [Aege] - Retired

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by lotri »

Garments also have the highest parry ratio, while armor has the highest durability. As an INT, you're more likely to die from physical attacks than from magical attacks.. so most people would suggest protector for you. Of course, garments will give you that extra 10% speed and higher parry, but you'll be more vulnerable to STR chars.
- Aege's former resident tactical medic

User avatar
The Invisible
Addicted Member
Posts: 2626
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2011 1:28 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Home ._.

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by The Invisible »

i don't get the point of pvp (unless ctf,battle arena,fortress war ) in other words group pvp anyway that's why i am using garment mostly ( wizz/bard ).
So in the first week in college i went with jeans and the pajama's shirt. Didn't notice what i was wearing till after i returned home.

User avatar
firefinal1
Active Member
Posts: 528
Joined: Fri Jan 11, 2008 11:38 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: The Netherland

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by firefinal1 »

The Invisible wrote:i don't get the point of pvp (unless ctf,battle arena,fortress war ) in other words group pvp anyway that's why i am using garment mostly ( wizz/bard ).


As wiz bard you dont have any other option ;)
Wiz = robe
Bard = robe
------------
Robes only :)
Image

User avatar
roe2121
Common Member
Posts: 116
Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 5:43 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: New South wales Australia

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by roe2121 »

lotri wrote:Garments also have the highest parry ratio, while armor has the highest durability. As an INT, you're more likely to die from physical attacks than from magical attacks.. so most people would suggest protector for you. Of course, garments will give you that extra 10% speed and higher parry, but you'll be more vulnerable to STR chars.

incorrect.. i had a robe top which had only 23 parry and a light armour chest i got had 37 parry.

also love all the underlying calculations makes it so awesome to make something strong without having to rely on the cookie cutter stuff everyone goes.
Server: Azteca
IGN: Euphy
Guild: N/A
6x Wizard/Cleric
IGN: Nodoka
Guild: Armathyx
6x S/s int hybrid

User avatar
aishsharma
Frequent Member
Posts: 1301
Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 3:58 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: SilkroadSalvation
Contact:

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by aishsharma »

roe2121 wrote:
lotri wrote:Garments also have the highest parry ratio, while armor has the highest durability. As an INT, you're more likely to die from physical attacks than from magical attacks.. so most people would suggest protector for you. Of course, garments will give you that extra 10% speed and higher parry, but you'll be more vulnerable to STR chars.

incorrect.. i had a robe top which had only 23 parry and a light armour chest i got had 37 parry.

also love all the underlying calculations makes it so awesome to make something strong without having to rely on the cookie cutter stuff everyone goes.


roe ur char is warrior/cleric if im reading your sig right :P
Spoiler!

Theseus - lvl 5x - warrior/rogue

User avatar
roe2121
Common Member
Posts: 116
Joined: Fri Mar 05, 2010 5:43 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: New South wales Australia

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by roe2121 »

wiz cleric actually and everyone asks me in every party why am i using lightning spells. as i find they are a good filler :roll:
Server: Azteca
IGN: Euphy
Guild: N/A
6x Wizard/Cleric
IGN: Nodoka
Guild: Armathyx
6x S/s int hybrid

User avatar
aishsharma
Frequent Member
Posts: 1301
Joined: Sun Aug 10, 2008 3:58 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: SilkroadSalvation
Contact:

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by aishsharma »

Well that's embarrassing :oops: . Can't believe i misread that...
Spoiler!

Theseus - lvl 5x - warrior/rogue

User avatar
The Invisible
Addicted Member
Posts: 2626
Joined: Sun Jan 23, 2011 1:28 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Home ._.

Re: Differnece between garm and prot

Post by The Invisible »

firefinal1 wrote:
The Invisible wrote:i don't get the point of pvp (unless ctf,battle arena,fortress war ) in other words group pvp anyway that's why i am using garment mostly ( wizz/bard ).


As wiz bard you dont have any other option ;)
Wiz = robe
Bard = robe
------------
Robes only :)

well i was wiz / cleric then changed to wizz / bard ( currently changing ) , i stopped leveling cleric at lv 30 as i don't like the skills and like bard skills more ( 850 cursed hearts for dlv 30 lv of cleric ,collected 150 still long way to go) and the cost for dlv about 17 m :shock: , it is good i am good at making gold . :sohappy:
So in the first week in college i went with jeans and the pajama's shirt. Didn't notice what i was wearing till after i returned home.

Post Reply

Return to “Silkroad General Discussion”