[Official] Comparison of Fire vs Light Dmg + Bonus ! <3

[Amro]

I myself prefer the Light/Fire nuker... Why? because you get 19% mag damage increase.. + fire being the strongest nukes in combination, it is way better for maximum damage..

and what about defence?

[Pan_Raider(`_´)]

Update: Have the Light imbue, however I'm already 106 due to how long it took to get the sp... think I should bother comparing the light imbue at all?

what other options do you have after coming so far?

[Goseki]

Update: Have the Light imbue, however I'm already 106 due to how long it took to get the sp... think I should bother comparing the light imbue at all?

what other options do you have after coming so far?

Well I guess I could just leave it out since it won't be accurate compared to when I was a fire nuker at 105... although I guess I can see if light ice imbue has the same diff as fire and ice imbue did... if someone wants the data i'll work on it when I get a chance. If not I'll prob leave the guide as is.

[Pan_Raider(`_´)]

nice progress
the damage with ice imbue+ light nuke means
fire/ice easily outdamaged by light/ice..

the only thing seeming slightly questionable is the minimal damage...
mangs hardly have defence or parry so the minimal damage might still be in the higher 50% of the spectrum.

But anyway, that is the minimal damage haha, the thought of having a friend debuff your attack rating to test it a dozen times then switch back to fire to see the effect there is hyperbolical <:-3

[Goseki]

nice progress
the damage with ice imbue+ light nuke means
fire/ice easily outdamaged by light/ice..

the only thing seeming slightly questionable is the minimal damage...
mangs hardly have defence or parry so the minimal damage might still be in the higher 50% of the spectrum.

But anyway, that is the minimal damage haha, the thought of having a friend debuff your attack rating to test it a dozen times then switch back to fire to see the effect there is hyperbolical <:-3

Not a chance, I'm luving light. With this cap with 106 being light's max, I'm prob gonna keep all skills at 106 and fire at 12 so I can be immune to all the status effects. At 102 light, i only hit 1k less than a 110 ff fire ice bich nuker with prem+ and +7 novas. He hit 31k on a warrior and I hit 30k when I had a silver prem.

[William-CL]

I myself prefer the Light/Fire nuker... Why? because you get 19% mag damage increase.. + fire being the strongest nukes in combination, it is way better for maximum damage..

and what about defence?

I'm pretty Fucked there lol. I'll go Cold with the remaining mastery though.

[IceCrash]

Why don't you guys get a blanket

[Goseki]

Why don't you guys get a blanket

???

[hitokiri]

Why don't you guys get a blanket

???

Cause hes getting cold

[Pan_Raider(`_´)]

now we need enlightment

[IceCrash]

someone among us... i feel that someone among us , is the special one. Because someone's been gifted with huge advantages! Advantages that shall help him rule the world, and save us from the darkness!!!

[sandsnip3r]

Give it a little time, and ill be sure to let you know. I have a fire/light/heuk nuker with 27 cold. A light/cold/heuk nuker. And im currently farming a fire/cold/heuk nuker. When they're all around the same level, ill let you know what i like. Ill tell you right now that the fire/light/heuk hits hard AS HELL.

[William-CL]

Give it a little time, and ill be sure to let you know. I have a fire/light/heuk nuker with 27 cold. A light/cold/heuk nuker. And im currently farming a fire/cold/heuk nuker. When they're all around the same level, ill let you know what i like. Ill tell you right now that the fire/light/heuk hits hard AS HELL.

That's a given with the Mag + Phys Damage increase. If End cap was 100, that would be a very good build.

[sandsnip3r]

Yeah, atm my light/ice is 101, my fire/light is 89, and im farming out the fire/ice with 1.6 mil sp

[Goseki]

Update:

Block Buff and Blade Force tested. SS laterz

Edit: You guys think this should stay in GD or be moved to guides???

[Pan_Raider(`_´)]

this is not really a guide, just an investigation to finally have empirical evidence for a long open question we could only speculate about.

[Tasdik]

this is not really a guide, just an investigation to finally have empirical evidence for a long open question we could only speculate about.

This.

FU Goske for ruining my whole fire/ice combo = bamf build.

/wrists

[drezo]

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Standard Build

Bicheon 110
Cold 110
Light 110

Light nuke » (1791 + 2938) + 119% = ~ 10357
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Experimental Build

Bicheon 110
Fire 110
Cold 80
Light 30

Fire nuke » (2026 + 3166) + 117% = ~11267
-----------------------------------------------------------------

This is from a thread I did a few months ago, but actually 28 light for mag buff and 82 ice for a bit more phy def. There's actually no point in testing, silkroad is a game. All there is to it is numbers. If you want brute results, just do an equation with all the variables.

[Goseki]

-----------------------------------------------------------------
Standard Build

Bicheon 110
Cold 110
Light 110

Light nuke » (1791 + 2938) + 119% = ~ 10357
-----------------------------------------------------------------
Experimental Build

Bicheon 110
Fire 110
Cold 80
Light 30

Fire nuke » (2026 + 3166) + 117% = ~11267
-----------------------------------------------------------------

This is from a thread I did a few months ago, but actually 28 light for mag buff and 82 ice for a bit more phy def. There's actually no point in testing, silkroad is a game. All there is to it is numbers. If you want brute results, just do an equation with all the variables.

That would only work if you knew the full damage calculation equation. I can tel you right now that thing you posted is missing quite a few parts.

[NuclearSilo]

phyDamage = (phyPow + Str*phyReinf + phySkill - phyDef)/(1+phyAbs/100)*(phyBal%)*(1+phyBuff%)*multiplier% * other variables.

same for magDamage

[Freon]

I had 98 fire/cold/heuksal/light(34) build but because lack off def Im switching to ice/light/bicheon so I currently have 98 lv fire/light/cold build so I made same test as in first post (only i was using light imbue instead of cold).
So here we go:

Min/max

fire/cold min:103 max:122
ice/light min:110 max:128

Average of 20 hits

fire/cold

Spoiler!

120
116
119
121
110
103
117
120
119
122
122
122
114
105
122
117
121
122
115
112

Average: 2339/20 = 116,95

cold/light:

Spoiler!

128
125
116
122
123
128
123
128
120
113
127
128
128
124
128
128
112
124
117
128

Average: 2470/20 = 123

BONUS

Spoiler!

fire/cold/+10% light, max:133
fire/cold/+18% light, max:141

I didnt made pic's cuz im lazy

[Goseki]

lol. Light ice bich 110 nuker wearing normal +5+6 garms has 200 phy def less than a fire heuk (ice/light mix) int hybrid wearing nova +9-+12 armor. XD