TheKnight's Sigs

[TheKnight]

Ok so I have made many sigs lately, but still can't decide what of them is the best, and I would like to have some ratings for them:

#1

Made this sometime ago, i think I've never used that color...

#2

My Newest, also the worst I think

#3

I think this is my favorite one

#4

This is very old one

#5

Made for a friend

#6

Clearly unfinished work, and old too...


So if you just could rate sigs and tell what i could do to make them better, i think I have .psd file from all of them...
Thanks everyone, and if you want use some of sigs, just ask (except #5 and#3)

[poehalcho]

I'm kinda liking #4

#1 7/10 I like the left , but it feels a bit awkward when it's the only sepient side,
#2 6/10 very monotone, bad font
#3 7.5/10 I can't really think of an improvement on this one... remove the tiny border on the left/right sides???
#4 8/10 very good light play, can't think of anything
#5 6.5/10 just boring, it's not bad, but the idea is just too simple =/. font isn't the greatest either again.
#6 5.5/10 ...bad choice of effect, has no left side....probably again a boring idea >.<

[fckerr]

Work on text

[Mirosuke]

again cant see until i right click and see in a new tab lol
how long usually u spend for a sig?

[TheKnight]

again cant see until i right click and see in a new tab lol
how long usually u spend for a sig?

Well it depends, around 10-20 min max.

[Swindler]

again cant see until i right click and see in a new tab lol
how long usually u spend for a sig?

Well it depends, around 10-20 min max.

Put more time and dedication into it.

[inky]

again cant see until i right click and see in a new tab lol
how long usually u spend for a sig?

Well it depends, around 10-20 min max.

Lol that's quick. I usually spend like 15 minutes - 3.5 hours (usually when experimenting with things I usually don't tamper with) on my stuff.

I like tutorials since I learn a lot from them but I only follow them strictly once - I use bits and pieces that I've learned from it after that, thus the long ass working time.

So far my faves from you are the Lich King and Illidan. Although, as I've said before, I would recommend going out of your comfort zone to try out new things - you know, add more gears to your arsenal.

Off Topic: One of my favorite mobs from SRO, Karas O.o

[Mirosuke]

again cant see until i right click and see in a new tab lol
how long usually u spend for a sig?

Well it depends, around 10-20 min max.

Well.. try to make a sig from scratch or at least make your own render.
o.0 Also, have more patience while doing it.
I know theres pretty much more to do on your sigs, its all depends on you.
You still have much moar potential...

[Deadsolid]

again cant see until i right click and see in a new tab lol
how long usually u spend for a sig?

Well it depends, around 10-20 min max.

I know I've already said this, but you need to spend more time on your sigs. In fact you should put the time it took you to make each sig in the subject of every post just so I'll know whether it is worth looking at.

I don't mean to be an ass, but you have to be honest with yourself. You can be as proud of your sigs as you want, but if the majority of C'n'C you get is negative, then you have to change your tactics otherwise you won't get any better.

Back on topic: you are showing improvement here and there. Obviously with time and more practice you'll have that, but I think it goes back to the time you spend on each sig. You definitely have some great ideas, you just need to follow through.

5 and 6 are great. The best I've seen from you so far at least. Great use of the canvas, text isnt fabulous, but overall pretty good.