Which Underbar Do you Prefer? *UPDATED!!!*

[Rainigul]

Code: Select all

Hi.

I'm starting a new UI package for the community, since I'm quite bored.
I've come up with 2 Concepts for a new skill bar.
Whichever bar is most liked by the community, I will use the same art style for the rest of the UI (Mp Bar, Loading screens etc)

Note: These bars are in their Alpha stages, but they give a general idea of the color schemes and styles used.
It would mean a lot to vote in the poll, and give and suggestions to their development below.

[u][b]UnderBar 1[/b][/u]
[img]http://i210.photobucket.com/albums/bb243/Sorrowsrage/UnderbarSROcopy-1.png[/img]

[u][b]UnderBar 2[/b][/u]
[img]http://i210.photobucket.com/albums/bb243/Sorrowsrage/UnderbarSROcopy.png[/img]

Thanks :)

----------------------UPDATE-------------------------

Here, is my new version. I used some elements from Underbar2, but i decided the color scheme was not working well on either underbar, so I went with a new approach.
This is my first draft of the new underbar and I think it's almost done.

Here it is:

Alone...



InGame...



I've closed the original poll, since that part of my research is over.
As always though, please vote and post any comments on the new bar

[Elviinxo]

The first one sucks...

[OnlyMe]

The first one sucks...

Nice comment..
It should be " The first one sucks because .... "
Ur comment is just plain stupid this way..

I like the first one more, because I don't like the boxes that much on the second one.

[Amro]

i like the second one more

[reLaxx`]

Add more green to the bottom one and it would be a lot better.

The background thing to the first one is too plain.

[Kirkaldi]

1st one for me lol. i like how it glows more.

[Jaapii]

Make something as good as this one

Spoiler!

and I'll use it^^

[Rainigul]

Make something as good as this one

Spoiler!

and I'll use it^^

That one is already online and available, it's not worth me importing it.

[Elviinxo]

The first one sucks...

Nice comment..
It should be " The first one sucks because it does "
Ur comment is just plain stupid this way..

I like the first one more, because I don't like the boxes that much on the second one.

[Jaapii]

Make something as good as this one

Spoiler!

and I'll use it^^

That one is already online and available, it's not worth me importing it.

that doesn't make it less sexy!

[XMoshe]

Neither are really my taste but #2 is the best of the two IMO

[Blindfire]

The colours need work.

[eestivend]

If you would add to the second one the ''U,esc,F10'' like on the first one i would use it

[Rainigul]

Thanks for the feedback so far guys. Keep the comments coming, I'm already thinking of ways to make the bars better, and I'll give an update to them in the near future.

Keep Voting!

[Saigon713]

Second one looks less distracting.

[penfold1992]

Make something as good as this one

Spoiler!

and I'll use it^^

i hate this one. it was used by many loaders/bots a while ago and when i see it i cannot seem to grasp the concept. this guy put the effort in and did it himself. i just think thats bs for the amount ive seen it.
my brother used 2 have it with his loader -.-

[Nitro]

my brother used 2 have it with his loader -.-

Dont ask why, but I lol'd.

OT: I dislike both of them, seen better, colours need some work.

[wootpops]

Neither are really my taste but #2 is the best of the two IMO

agreed.. i guess it will flow more with places like dw and stuff but once your onto other landscapes it's gonna stick out like crazy.

[GimmeMo]

I like both o_O

[ninshad]

make all the slotbars you want, it wont make sro a better game

[Thomas42]

Voted for #2. Although I think you should make it a little more greyish.

[CloudStrider]

my brother used 2 have it with his loader -.-

Dont ask why, but I lol'd.

OT: I dislike both of them, seen better, colours need some work.

Yeah...my friend also has it, you know, not me.

J/ks!

[Green Tea]

2, bcuz of oldschool, for me

[*BlackFox]

I like the second one better.

[Razorhead]

Underbar 1:
Too many lines & ugly color(s), i get a headache from looking at it ><
The green is nice though, U might want to change the color from the box that shows sp, cuz it's hard to read the amount of SP; or change the color of the SP

Underbar 2:
Brown isn't my thing
The lines are nicely done, but they shouldn't overlap I/u/Esc/F10 buttons
The skillslot isn't that nice cuz only the first one matches the lines & the others don't match the 'total'.
Missing Arrows (above/under F1)

Atm, underbar 1 is my favorite, but that brown with black&brown lines ruins the underbar for me

[Rainigul]

Well.

It seems that according to the poll, most people are in favor of UnderBar 2.
So, I will be doing a new version of it, and incorporating some elements of UnderBar 1 as well as your suggestions into it.

So hopefully I can release a new version relatively soon.

[penfold1992]

my brother used 2 have it with his loader -.-

Dont ask why, but I lol'd.

OT: I dislike both of them, seen better, colours need some work.

Yeah...my friend also has it, you know, not me.

J/ks!

lol i know its a common excuse but its true. he sucks at every mmorpg and the same as my friend irl however this paticular friend is legit.
every time i outlevel them they quit. SRO FlyFF WoW Mu online JD he just sucks ass.
and yea my brother bots. and my friends bot too. if you can prove i bot (if any1 has there doubts) then ill give you my account my laptop and my pc if you can prove i bot.
(DOESNT COUNT FOR JD CLOUD!!! lol that would be a little bit unfair on my behalf xD)

all my friends pick on me for being like a UBER legit xD

[CloudStrider]

Lol, was about to post a JD s/s.

[rek]

The first one sucks...

Nice comment..
It should be " The first one sucks because it does "
Ur comment is just plain stupid this way..

I like the first one more, because I don't like the boxes that much on the second one.

smartass


warned

[CloudStrider]

My sarcasm detector was broken on this post. ^