Alchemy Bug...

PocketSunshine · Post by **PocketSunshine** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 5:03 pm

I have my most luck with 20% stones. 10% stones usually never work for me.

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:28 pm

firefox6 wrote:ok think about how many stones you use up and one fails and set something to 0.. really 10 out of a 100 (if you use 10% stones) stones assimilate and it is a bug.. no it is juts bad luck

not everything that goes wrong for you is a bug.

You guys reading skills are terrible. In case you missed it, almost ALL 5 and 10% stones assimilate. Not 10 out of 100. Comparing this to previous months of alchemy, something is different. Why do you think so many people have replied saying "yes, something is wrong".

.curve, same goes for you. You really should go try some alchemy before posting.. There are 2 pics in this thread supporting what we've said. You honestly think its just coincidence that I log on, use a 10% stone and it assims? Same for the following poster?

Sigh, guess I'll go waste some gold on 10% stones and take more pics for those of you too lazy to log in and see for yourself.

EDIT: Pics or it didn't happen? Why would I waste my time with this topic if it wasn't true? If alchemy was behaving like it normally does then I couldn't careless..

.curve · Post by **.curve** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:48 pm

Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

CeLL · Post by **CeLL** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:56 pm

.curve wrote:Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

no you didnt you moron, you didnt show what the stones % was b4 you used it. that screenie could be a year old.

Shadowfox542 · Post by **Shadowfox542** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 7:59 pm

CeLL wrote:
.curve wrote:Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

Spoiler!

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

no you didnt you moron, you didnt show what the stones % was b4 you used it. that screenie could be a year old.

Hyrdra Blaze Robe=May 20th 2008 at earliest.

outlawz · Post by **outlawz** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 8:07 pm

JM probably f**k around with the alchemy system to make you buy prem +
Greedy bastards :banghead:

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 8:35 pm

Well, in reply, and sorry this wasn't stated. Seems to only be a problem with attribute stones. My mistake, but it is only with pink attribute stones. Test it out.

EDIT: I tested out a few more attribute stones, all assimilated. Will post pics in a few.

CeLL · Post by **CeLL** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 8:54 pm

Shadowfox542 wrote:
CeLL wrote:
.curve wrote:Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

Spoiler!

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

no you didnt you moron, you didnt show what the stones % was b4 you used it. that screenie could be a year old.

Hyrdra Blaze Robe=May 20th 2008 at earliest.

you know what i mean.

_EagleEye_ · Post by **_EagleEye_** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 11:12 pm

.curve wrote:Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

wow thats funny cuz am i the only one who got bad luck, or the other 20+ ppl on xian? whos stats went from 60%+ to 0%.. funny huh?

.curve · Post by **.curve** » Fri Jan 16, 2009 11:36 pm

advisor wrote:
.curve wrote:Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

wow thats funny cuz am i the only one who got bad luck, or the other 20+ ppl on xian? whos stats went from 60%+ to 0%.. funny huh?

Oh my god, you mean 20/3500 people failed alchemy? Must obviously mean something is up.

Wait, wait. More proof:

10% Attribute Stone of Challenge

Lvl 76 +3 2h Sword, feel free to write down the stats

The result, check the bottom right

RogueKiller · Post by **RogueKiller** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:01 am

20 from Xian. At least 40 from my union. About 10-15 friends from other unions. Added to the people mentioning it on these forums. Plus the globals of people mentioning this.
Yup...Just a coincidence. We suck at alchemy. That must be it....

.curve · Post by **.curve** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:13 am

Honestly...sounds like a bunch of people QQing because they failed at alchemy. Suck it up and move on.

_EagleEye_ · Post by **_EagleEye_** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:15 am

.curve wrote:Honestly...sounds like a bunch of people QQing because they failed at alchemy. Suck it up and move on.

oh btw i saw this happen to about 20 ppl in like 30mins lol i bet the turks r prolly goin crazy

.curve · Post by **.curve** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:16 am

advisor wrote:
.curve wrote:Honestly...sounds like a bunch of people QQing because they failed at alchemy. Suck it up and move on.

oh btw i saw this happen to about 20 ppl in like 30mins lol i bet the turks r prolly goin crazy

And I've seen nothing about it on my server. And I even disproved that it's a "bug" with my screen shots.

_EagleEye_ · Post by **_EagleEye_** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:18 am

delete plz

Ragnorak · Post by **Ragnorak** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:28 am

.curve wrote:
advisor wrote:
.curve wrote:Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

wow thats funny cuz am i the only one who got bad luck, or the other 20+ ppl on xian? whos stats went from 60%+ to 0%.. funny huh?

Oh my god, you mean 20/3500 people failed alchemy? Must obviously mean something is up.

Wait, wait. More proof:

10% Attribute Stone of Challenge

Lvl 76 +3 2h Sword, feel free to write down the stats

The result, check the bottom right

congrats you proved that attribute stones don't fail
how do I know that you didn't scroll down to hide "attribute assimilation"?
or maybe show another success or guild member has log in ect.
just a thought

Toshiharu · Post by **Toshiharu** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:30 am

Assimilation appears above the actual stat change.

BalkanFanaticS · Post by **BalkanFanaticS** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:54 am

.curve wrote:Holy shit, I just disproved your "bug"

10% Stamina stone. Do you see an assimilation? Nope. k bai. Now start blaming the SRO gods for your bad luck.

ur yello boxes :oops:

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 12:57 am

Wrong, its random...sometimes below..sometimes above.

EDIT: Pics posted out of order sorry, boots first, earrings second. The 4 10% stones I've used today, same results as past few days. If you don't believe it now, fine. And omG HaX0rs what are the chances that..omg...it's not a problem on Venus? ZOMG!#? But I know for a fact it is on Troy.

(the first training stone failed, as seen in the screenshots.)

Also, why do you want this thread deleted now? Geez you people..

.curve · Post by **.curve** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 2:16 am

1. I'm not actually on Venus. I'll change that in a second.
2. I told you it's a random system. All I was trying to disprove was that it's a "bug" as the op stated.
3. @Balkan, haha I know. Lurked around here enough to know what people will call me on.

It's been a fun discussion with you all, good bye.

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 3:51 am

Indeed it was a fun discussion. It's just that I've been doing alchemy long enough (LOTS of alchemy) that I know when something is up. Having every single 10% stone assim isn't a case of "shit luck".

In the meantime, I've been using 20% stones with pretty good results, 20 and 30 are "performing" as they should. lol.

Edit: lol...

.curve · Post by **.curve** » Sat Jan 17, 2009 10:58 pm

EvGa wrote:Indeed it was a fun discussion. It's just that I've been doing alchemy long enough (LOTS of alchemy) that I know when something is up. Having every single 10% stone assim isn't a case of "shit luck".

In the meantime, I've been using 20% stones with pretty good results, 20 and 30 are "performing" as they should. lol.

Edit: lol...

Might be your server then, idk. I've had pretty good luck with alchemy so far, usually 2-3 stones gets me my results, with very little assimilation.
Rofl at the pic, can't really complain about that last assim/success.

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 2:31 am

Seems today no matter what % stone I had assimilation. Again, this only seems to happen with attribute stones and not green stones. Pretty awesome how many worked in a row... not so awesome is the number of assimilation. The headpiece ended up with 0/41/22/40/0/0 white stats and 100% blues lol. I'lll try fixing whites once they get this mess sorted out.

AT ORIGINAL POSTER Please change the title back to what it was, there is no reason to delete this thread. I think people should see and be warned before doing any alchemy.. Could only be happening on a few servers, but better that people see it.. The following isn't coincidence.

Ragnorak · Post by **Ragnorak** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 2:57 am

just bad luck -.-

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 3:11 am

lol yeah right ragu.

Disconn3cted · Post by **Disconn3cted** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 3:26 am

I don't have this problem, for me 5% stones assimilate the least and 35% assimilate the most. I think you guys are just having bad luck.

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 3:49 am

Different server.

In case you missed it, every attribute stone I've used (on Troy) assimilates. I've posted many screenshots.. Ask anyone who's done alchemy, that's not just bad luck. Same results on two different accounts. One with prem+ one with silver prem.

Wish they would fix this... Blues are fine, but trying to change any white is a nightmare.

HDEV · Post by **HDEV** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 4:12 am

I confirm also this bug, every stone I tried to use to change white stat assimilated other stat, happened with 10%, 20% and 30% ... I used more than 40 stones, all was on protector items, and every success stone made assimilation, all was pink stones. No problems when adding blues.

EvGa · Post by **EvGa** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 4:49 am

Interesting location. O.o

_EagleEye_ · Post by **_EagleEye_** » Sun Jan 18, 2009 8:52 am

today some guy on xian did globals that ur stats will assimilate 80% of the time when u use 5-10% stones

Silkroad Online Forums

Alchemy Bug...

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: delete plz

Re: Alchemy Bug

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: delete plz

Re: Alchemy Bug...