Tough call. Second one has higher attack rating. BUT first one if +1ed would have the same if not higher mag dmg than the second one which is already +1. Crit doesnt matter jack shit for a nuker so the second ones crit is useless. I recommned to add attack rating stones and weap elixers to the first one and make it +3. Its already a decent spear...just needs some spiffing up.
I am....
Stefan87: Level 5x Pure Int Fire/Light Dual Nuker. --------- GRRR: Level 5x Gnaws on low lvl thieves.