to + or not to + i need you opionions

[Rakion]

i read some advice from ppl who have good luck on there side...
i bought it on a stall worth 400K+ or something but what i'm interested about is its crit. and luck i made it +3...
now its up you your opinion...

well?

[Goobronicus]

The problem with plussing is it's like drugs, once you start you can't stop (joking).

Actually, it is a problem, because if you get it to +4, you're going to want to go for +5, and then +6, etc. TBH, I settled for +3 weapons until 64 (start of 8D weapons) and then went +5 till 80. Course, I'm a wizard so I'm already too powerful even with a +3.

Did it go to +3 really easily (or did you buy it +3 and I just didn't understand). If it went easy, go for 4, if not, get it back to 3 again and be happy.

[Rakion]

Did it go to +3 really easily (or did you buy it +3 and I just didn't understand). If it went easy, go for 4, if not, get it back to 3 again and be happy.

yes it did... it was +1 first with 6 lucky

[tedtwilliger]

So it used 2 luckies trying to get to +3? I wouldn't bother +'ing it any further, just sell it now.

[Rakion]

So it used 2 luckies trying to get to +3? I wouldn't bother +'ing it any further, just sell it now.

what do you mean?...

[tedtwilliger]

So it used 2 luckies trying to get to +3? I wouldn't bother +'ing it any further, just sell it now.

what do you mean?...

Did it go to +3 really easily (or did you buy it +3 and I just didn't understand). If it went easy, go for 4, if not, get it back to 3 again and be happy.

yes it did... it was +1 first with 6 lucky

Well if i understand correctly, it had 6 lucky's originally. Now getting to +3 is one of the easiest alchemy benchmarks to do. Now if you used 2 lucky's trying to get to the +3, than my best instinct tells me that your weapon has a low natural luck value.. and the chance of getting +5 wouldn't be too great despite you having 4 lucky's still remaining. For this reason i wouldnt try to +5 it.

[bomben]

just try
if it fails u can easily get it +3 again anyways

[Rakion]

So it used 2 luckies trying to get to +3? I wouldn't bother +'ing it any further, just sell it now.

what do you mean?...

Did it go to +3 really easily (or did you buy it +3 and I just didn't understand). If it went easy, go for 4, if not, get it back to 3 again and be happy.

yes it did... it was +1 first with 6 lucky

Well if i understand correctly, it had 6 lucky's originally. Now getting to +3 is one of the easiest alchemy benchmarks to do. Now if you used 2 lucky's trying to get to the +3, than my best instinct tells me that your weapon has a low natural luck value.. and the chance of getting +5 wouldn't be too great despite you having 4 lucky's still remaining. For this reason i wouldnt try to +5 it.

ok... i think i'll play safe.

but i'm still not convinced, anyways tnx for contributing your opinion tedtwilliger. you have set my mind to 75% not to +5 it.

[wicked]

So it used 2 luckies trying to get to +3? I wouldn't bother +'ing it any further, just sell it now.

what do you mean?...

Did it go to +3 really easily (or did you buy it +3 and I just didn't understand). If it went easy, go for 4, if not, get it back to 3 again and be happy.

yes it did... it was +1 first with 6 lucky

Well if i understand correctly, it had 6 lucky's originally. Now getting to +3 is one of the easiest alchemy benchmarks to do. Now if you used 2 lucky's trying to get to the +3, than my best instinct tells me that your weapon has a low natural luck value.. and the chance of getting +5 wouldn't be too great despite you having 4 lucky's still remaining. For this reason i wouldnt try to +5 it.

Haha, that the biggest bull shit i ever heard, i lol'ed to for a sec
There's no such thing as "natural luck value"
own decission IMO.

[Super8]

plus it until either you get +5 or all the luckies are gone.
+3 is EASY.

[aruin]

omg DEAL>. +9 it

[LillDev!l]

hehe, i think a wep DOES have its own luck value.
since some weps go + 7 or even +9 in 1 try.
others go +6, fail +7 and go to +5/6 just as easely again.

others simpely wont reach +5 no matter how hard you try.

i agree with tedtwilliger, using 2 luckies to go to +3, wont have to much of a chance going to +4/5.

[wicked]

-.- when u put luck on ur wep u automatically use the luck even when u try it +1...
Alchemy shit is all based on LUCK, LUCK and LUCK. No things like natural luck.

[_Shinigami_]

i would not +

even with luck, its going to fail

[LillDev!l]

-.- when u put luck on ur wep u automatically use the luck even when u try it +1...

not true xD ive +'ed enough weps with lucky, sometimes the lucky just stays on it

[Ryoko]

-.- when u put luck on ur wep u automatically use the luck even when u try it +1...

not true xD ive +'ed enough weps with lucky, sometimes the lucky just stays on it

See also

Don't think anyone knows how lucky 'truly' works. Neither do I. But heres a hypothetical theory.

You fail. You use a lucky. Its not enough - you still fail.
You fail. You use a lucky. Its enough - and succeeds.
You succeed. No lucky used.

From
viewtopic.php?f=5&t=18488&start=0&st=0&sk=t&sd=a

[tedtwilliger]

Haha, that the biggest bull shit i ever heard, i lol'ed to for a sec
There's no such thing as "natural luck value"
own decission IMO.

Your actually wrong. Proof is as follows.



Next time dont say anything unless you can back it up.

[Rakion]

i made a poll