[Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Here you can post guides and tutorials you have written for Silkroad Online. If submitting a guide from another forum, please post credit to the author.
Post Reply
User avatar
CHIPS
Regular Member
Posts: 298
Joined: Fri Jul 20, 2007 12:27 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Zeus

[Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by CHIPS »

I am going to talk about SP gapping in this guide. I hope that it will be helpful for you, in deciding how much SP gap you should keep. Firstly, take a look at this table I made here. The table might be hard to understand at first. But read on and you will understand.

Image

The SP gapping system in SRO is pretty simple. For example,if you maintain a 2 gap between your mastery and your current level (e.g. you keep your mastery at lvl 40, while your actual level is 42), you will earn only 80% the original exp and 120% the original sp. So if you killed a mob who was supposed to give you 1000 exp and exactly 1 sp, with 2 sp gap you will get 800 exp and 1.2sp. Currently SRO allows a maximum gap of 9.

Now take a look at column A, B and C of the table. Column A is numbered 1 to 9, where 9 is the maximum GAP allowed in SRO. Column B and C states the exp and sp, in percentage, that one will get at each gap. For example, at maximum 9 gap, one will get 10% the original exp and 190% the original sp.

Columns D,E and F is the cost-benefit analyst of each sp gap. Column D compares the exp lost when moving from the current gap to the next gap. For example, let's say you are currently at 2 gap, and considering going to 3 gap. As a result, you will go from 80% exp to 70% exp. The exp lost that you will suffer is (70-80)/80=-0.125=12.5% lost of exp. An more obvious example will be going from 8 gap to 9 gap, where you will suffer (10-20)/20=50.00% exp lost.

Column E compares the sp gain when moving from the current gap to the next gap. If you understand column D, this should be self-explanatory.

As you notice, the proportion of exp lost increases with a bigger gap, and the proportion of sp gain decreases. This leads us to column F, which calculates the ratio between the exp lost to the sp gained. For example, when you are going from 5 gap to 6 gap, you lost 20% exp and gains 6.67% sp. The cost benefit of this is 20/6.67=3 times. That means, you are sacrificing 3% of exp, in exchange for 1% of sp gain when going from 5 gap to 6 gap relatively.

Conclusion:
As you can see, the best choices are at 0 or 1 gap, since the trade-off ratio is one to one. Starting from the gap of 2, players will take increasing punishment as the gap increases. Until finally going from 8 gap to 9 gap, the players will be lossing 50% of exp in exchange for 5.56% of extra sp relatively. In other words for 9 gap, the players will be leveling twice as slowly, and getting only 5.56% more sp than 8 gap.

We can conclude that having giant sp gaps does not help. Increasing the gap cause one to lost more exp than the sp gain. So trying to zero gap, and then maxing gap later is the wrong approach. The best way for gapping is to keep a small constant gap throughout the whole character. The best is probably 3-4 gap all the way, since the ratio is still smaller than 2 before 4 gap.

User avatar
ryanh55
Regular Member
Posts: 226
Joined: Tue May 29, 2007 7:37 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Venus

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by ryanh55 »

fantastic!!! very nice work..
Image

Name: Propofol lvl 87 Cleric/bard
Server: Venus
Guild: Ninjitsu

daily montra: All because you can does not mean you should![code][/code]

Zinan
Common Member
Posts: 109
Joined: Sat Sep 22, 2007 6:59 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Odin

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by Zinan »

Ive always had a lot of questions about SP farming and the such, this helped. thx a lot ^^
<<banned from SRF for bot admission. -SG>>

User avatar
wicked
Valued Member
Posts: 353
Joined: Sun Dec 02, 2007 9:59 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: azteca

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by wicked »

Yea, nice how you figured this out :D
But lvling all the way 4 gaped is a hell, tho 9 gap just aint that nice, u'll need it.
__________________________________________________________
Obviously - Warrior/Cleric - lv.102 - Armathyx*GermanLover

HejsaN wrote:
SoleFressshhhh wrote:Roses are red, Pickles are green. I like your legs, whats in between?


Just a penis, why do you ask?

User avatar
nohunta
Loyal Member
Posts: 1561
Joined: Sun Jun 17, 2007 7:06 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Off Topic Lounge

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by nohunta »

4 gap LOL Gl.
Image

Playing Jade Dynasty
2x Lupin Wdfmymoney

User avatar
Feataler
Active Member
Posts: 603
Joined: Sun Dec 23, 2007 10:44 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Venus

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by Feataler »

nohunta wrote:4 gap LOL Gl.

with a 4 gap you'll be lvl 50 before a lvl 16 with 9 gap finishes farming.

lol gl
Image

User avatar
GodsAngel
Valued Member
Posts: 467
Joined: Sun Oct 01, 2006 5:56 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Venus

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by GodsAngel »

but it's not like you can consistently level effectively from level 1 -> 80. the mob spawn varies, the parties vary(for euro).

so it depends on the server, the person and the situation. It's a good piece of work you did there though, enlightening.
Euro- Mob baller * 1hand
ign: IAmZeeDevil
Guild:-=Avalon=-
gonna miss you all but I've officially quit silkroad :)
Current Projects
Comprehensive European Party Guide - -15% done
(currently setback)
Warrior Guide - -45% done
(working hard)

User avatar
Perseus
Common Member
Posts: 174
Joined: Mon Nov 12, 2007 1:24 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Venus

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by Perseus »

Finally glad to see someone proving that SP farming is a waste of time. :D

User avatar
IguanaRampage
Advanced Member
Posts: 2483
Joined: Fri Jul 14, 2006 1:37 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Changing

Re: [Guide] The Magic of SP Gapping, a Cost-Benefit Analyst

Post by IguanaRampage »

Well yeah, from this perspective, SP farming looks like a waste of time. However, in reality, this isn't true, because often people SP farm where there are incredible spawn rates (ex: nachals or bandit stronghold). I'd rather have a 9 gap on nachals than have a 4 gap on bunwangs with all the gold bots there to be frank. Considering that there are many bots in a lot of the good-spawn places though, gapping provides a great alternative to farming. Nice analysis.
McCain, he (Barack Obama) said, will soon "be accusing me of being a secret communist because I shared my toys in kindergarten."

Post Reply

Return to “Guides and Tutorials”