70:70 spear vs 70:70 glaive

Discuss building Silkroad characters and learning skill trees. Ask for advice and opinions, or help others.
Post Reply
DragonEngine
New Member
Posts: 38
Joined: Fri Nov 30, 2007 11:36 am

70:70 spear vs 70:70 glaive

Post by DragonEngine »

Does anyone have either of these builds? I'm talking about phys/mag balance of course. And if so then I would assume that spear does more damage if you have this build, is that correct? The reason being NOT becaues 70:70 is more INT (the fact that it's 70:70 makes it irrelevant how much of each stat you have placed), but because Spear's phys+mag COMBINED attack power is greater than glaive's. Is that right?

User avatar
muyo
Valued Member
Posts: 425
Joined: Thu Oct 12, 2006 4:48 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Middle Earth

Post by muyo »

glaivier:More HP,Lower Damage
spearman:Less HP,More Damage

70's vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGqptrMRVAs

Glaive vid is easier to find :D

User avatar
Trice
Ex-Staff
Posts: 2364
Joined: Mon Jun 11, 2007 3:48 pm
Location: Everywhere. All the Time... But more specifically, England

Post by Trice »

muyo wrote:glaivier:More HP,Lower Damage
spearman:Less HP,More Damage

70's vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGqptrMRVAs

Glaive vid is easier to find :D


less hp because? O_o

aint he asking whats better to use when his str and int are the same?


spear if you are gonna do some nukes

else i would suggest you get npc versions of each for the degree you are, and test some attacks out on mobs, see what does more. then you know whether to go spear or glaive :P
Last edited by Trice on Mon Dec 10, 2007 12:43 pm, edited 2 times in total.
My stories + songs
Story Search: [Story] author Trice
Parody Search: [Parody] author Trice

Image
Image
Ty cin :love:
Sarcasm makes you more attractive to the opposite sex

User avatar
X20AFreedom
Regular Member
Posts: 248
Joined: Sun Mar 12, 2006 5:59 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Xian

Post by X20AFreedom »

muyo wrote:glaivier:More HP,Lower Damage
spearman:Less HP,More Damage

70's vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGqptrMRVAs

Glaive vid is easier to find :D


dun make sense ... if im 70/70 at lvl 81 i got 220 int and 220 str using spear i still has the same amount of hp as glavie user as long as i got the same lvl cheolsam force.

Spear/Glavie is up to u.If u nuke u might wanna get Spear if u use chain combos, go glavie
Glavie/Spear/Bow 1 str 2 int build - Defense Equipments Armor - Ice Force Keep str at 220 at lvl 81.lvl 100 snow shield needs 60%.at lvl 81 ur str and int is 220 220 which is 50%.75 phy balance 62 mag balance build.
Blade/Sword 3 str 0 int build Defense Equipments Garment - Fire
Bow 24 str 6 int build per 10 lvl. Defense Equipments Protector - Lightning.88% phy balance 42%mag balance build

User avatar
Doctor_MOS
Active Member
Posts: 957
Joined: Wed Apr 18, 2007 4:24 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Venice

Post by Doctor_MOS »

X20AFreedom wrote:
muyo wrote:glaivier:More HP,Lower Damage
spearman:Less HP,More Damage

70's vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGqptrMRVAs

Glaive vid is easier to find :D


dun make sense ... if im 70/70 at lvl 81 i got 220 int and 220 str using spear i still has the same amount of hp as glavie user as long as i got the same lvl cheolsam force.

Spear/Glavie is up to u.If u nuke u might wanna get Spear if u use chain combos, go glavie
lol, are u saying 70:70 got the same amount of hp as a full str glavie?

Guys, 70:70 is something totally different, you won't have the same amount of hp/mp

70:70 is leaning towards 1:2 str:int...Just slight more str
Image

User avatar
X20AFreedom
Regular Member
Posts: 248
Joined: Sun Mar 12, 2006 5:59 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Xian

Post by X20AFreedom »

Doctor_MOS wrote:
X20AFreedom wrote:
muyo wrote:glaivier:More HP,Lower Damage
spearman:Less HP,More Damage

70's vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGqptrMRVAs

Glaive vid is easier to find :D


dun make sense ... if im 70/70 at lvl 81 i got 220 int and 220 str using spear i still has the same amount of hp as glavie user as long as i got the same lvl cheolsam force.

Spear/Glavie is up to u.If u nuke u might wanna get Spear if u use chain combos, go glavie
lol, are u saying 70:70 got the same amount of hp as a full str glavie?

Guys, 70:70 is something totally different, you won't have the same amount of hp/mp

70:70 is leaning towards 1:2 str:int...Just slight more str

lol
look the topic its 70:70 vs 70:70 which means u compare 70:70 with 70:70 glavie not full str glavie.

it seems to look like u r the 1st person who mention full str glavie in this thread
Glavie/Spear/Bow 1 str 2 int build - Defense Equipments Armor - Ice Force Keep str at 220 at lvl 81.lvl 100 snow shield needs 60%.at lvl 81 ur str and int is 220 220 which is 50%.75 phy balance 62 mag balance build.
Blade/Sword 3 str 0 int build Defense Equipments Garment - Fire
Bow 24 str 6 int build per 10 lvl. Defense Equipments Protector - Lightning.88% phy balance 42%mag balance build

User avatar
Doctor_MOS
Active Member
Posts: 957
Joined: Wed Apr 18, 2007 4:24 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Venice

Post by Doctor_MOS »

X20AFreedom wrote:
Doctor_MOS wrote:
X20AFreedom wrote:
muyo wrote:glaivier:More HP,Lower Damage
spearman:Less HP,More Damage

70's vid: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JGqptrMRVAs

Glaive vid is easier to find :D


dun make sense ... if im 70/70 at lvl 81 i got 220 int and 220 str using spear i still has the same amount of hp as glavie user as long as i got the same lvl cheolsam force.

Spear/Glavie is up to u.If u nuke u might wanna get Spear if u use chain combos, go glavie
lol, are u saying 70:70 got the same amount of hp as a full str glavie?

Guys, 70:70 is something totally different, you won't have the same amount of hp/mp

70:70 is leaning towards 1:2 str:int...Just slight more str

lol
look the topic its 70:70 vs 70:70 which means u compare 70:70 with 70:70 glavie not full str glavie.

it seems to look like u r the 1st person who mention full str glavie in this thread

Lol sorry my bad
*and i putted a question mark behind it, i didn't fully understand it you see?
Image

User avatar
muyo
Valued Member
Posts: 425
Joined: Thu Oct 12, 2006 4:48 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Middle Earth

Post by muyo »

:D

my bad,i though full str glaive...70's is consider as int base...so go for spear

DragonEngine
New Member
Posts: 38
Joined: Fri Nov 30, 2007 11:36 am

Post by DragonEngine »

mm I think I asked the wrong question.I don't want to be a nuker, I want to use regular melee attacks. I think these two are better to compare:

70:70 spear
or
75:62 glaive (equal str and int)

Which does more damage (not counting crit)?

User avatar
doomas
Valued Member
Posts: 380
Joined: Mon Aug 07, 2006 8:35 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Eos

Post by doomas »

DragonEngine wrote:mm I think I asked the wrong question.I don't want to be a nuker, I want to use regular melee attacks. I think these two are better to compare:

70:70 spear
or
75:62 glaive (equal str and int)

Which does more damage (not counting crit)?

70:70 would do more dmg. More int = more dmg

As for 70:70 spear / glavie, i think spear is a better choise. As some one has already mentioned that buy npc glavie and spear and then compare the dmg. Spear should do more dmg...

User avatar
Hasbin
Regular Member
Posts: 230
Joined: Thu Sep 14, 2006 10:27 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Venice

Post by Hasbin »

doomas wrote:
DragonEngine wrote:mm I think I asked the wrong question.I don't want to be a nuker, I want to use regular melee attacks. I think these two are better to compare:

70:70 spear
or
75:62 glaive (equal str and int)

Which does more damage (not counting crit)?

70:70 would do more dmg. More int = more dmg

As for 70:70 spear / glavie, i think spear is a better choise. As some one has already mentioned that buy npc glavie and spear and then compare the dmg. Spear should do more dmg...


And has higher crit possibilty
Quitted sro
Playing cabal
lvl 13x FS
Trans/Trans

Post Reply

Return to “Characters and Skills”