Warrior/cleric or rogue/cleric best in 1on1 pvp?

[-.-]

no one mentioned this so far but warrior normally does better fighting rogues because of their phy def
since both do all phy, warrior has phy def passives and heavy armor

but fighting other builds they are more even since other builds have mag attacks so rogues light armor works a bit more
(well warrior would use light armor for passive with cleric maybe, but it has phy def passives from warrior also)

[raphaell666]

no one mentioned this so far but warrior normally does better fighting rogues because of their phy def
since both do all phy, warrior has phy def passives and heavy armor

but fighting other builds they are more even since other builds have mag attacks so rogues light armor works a bit more
(well warrior would use light armor for passive with cleric maybe, but it has phy def passives from warrior also)

Basically only 1handed has physical defense increasing passive, as well as blocking passives (dual axes aren't actually equipped for a long time if the warrior has them, they generally only use it for bleed and stun, and therefore I do not count it's physical defense passive), and as we've already got to the conclusion, the 1hander has somewhat some advantage over rogues. Also, I don't think warriors should be wearing heavy armor at cap, but whatever. The rogue can get the passives from cleric as well.