Silkroad Online Forums

You have the choice between two weapons.
One has Physical power of 8% and Physical reinforce of 51%
Second has Physical power of 51% and Physical reinforce of 8%

What would you chose ?

8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

RogueKiller wrote:8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

MUAHAAAAAAAA u have mugen on ur avatar!!
ON topic:They're exactly the same,but i'd take the 8%phy and 51%phy reinf=)

RogueKiller wrote:8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

Same thought Pretty obvious question.

With 51% phy reinforce any time for me to use. But if i need to sell it I would chose with 51% phy, since most noobs think is reinforce isnt important like phy

XMoshe wrote:

RogueKiller wrote:8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

Same thought Pretty obvious question.

/agree

maybe you could explain why you think so? It would help the discussion I think

two quotes;

TotalDmg =
(((weapPhyPower + Str*phyReinforce + phySkillPower)*(1 + weapMastery) - phyDef) * phyBalance * skillMultiplier * phyBuff * multiplier)

Phy. Atk = [Phy. attack power + (Str stat * Phy. Reinforce)] * [1 + weapon mastery/100]

Since multiplication > addition, reinforcement is more important
/endofdiscussion

Mousetrap wrote:two quotes;

TotalDmg =
(((weapPhyPower + Str*phyReinforce + phySkillPower)*(1 + weapMastery) - phyDef) * phyBalance * skillMultiplier * phyBuff * multiplier)

Phy. Atk = [Phy. attack power + (Str stat * Phy. Reinforce)] * [1 + weapon mastery/100]

Since multiplication > addition, reinforcement is more important
/endofdiscussion

ok agreed then
/endofdiscussion
PS: btw that is what I knew and said, my buyer did not agree. Well life goes on

EDIT: why is the vote 5/5 when nobody said that 51% attack is better than 51% reinforce ????

neither, horrible stats.

Ragnorak wrote:neither, horrible stats.

never done this b4... but...

+1!

phy attack power of a weapon has more to do with its dmg than the reinforce which is not to say the reinforce doesn't matter

Depends on your relative character level and if you are pure int/str or hybrid.

So I think the answer depends on your character more than a general one is better than the other.

Either one. They'll end up meeting the rondo.