What would you take?

[REBD]

You have the choice between two weapons.
One has Physical power of 8% and Physical reinforce of 51%
Second has Physical power of 51% and Physical reinforce of 8%

What would you chose ?

[RogueKiller]

8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

[BonG]

8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

MUAHAAAAAAAA u have mugen on ur avatar!!
ON topic:They're exactly the same,but i'd take the 8%phy and 51%phy reinf=)

[XMoshe]

8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

Same thought Pretty obvious question.

[_MvP_]

With 51% phy reinforce any time for me to use. But if i need to sell it I would chose with 51% phy, since most noobs think is reinforce isnt important like phy

[Lempi]

8%-51%
My choice.
Edit: 1 or 2 stones could fix the 8% phy power.

Same thought Pretty obvious question.

/agree

[REBD]

maybe you could explain why you think so? It would help the discussion I think

[Mousetrap]

two quotes;

TotalDmg =
(((weapPhyPower + Str*phyReinforce + phySkillPower)*(1 + weapMastery) - phyDef) * phyBalance * skillMultiplier * phyBuff * multiplier)

Phy. Atk = [Phy. attack power + (Str stat * Phy. Reinforce)] * [1 + weapon mastery/100]

Since multiplication > addition, reinforcement is more important
/endofdiscussion

[REBD]

two quotes;

TotalDmg =
(((weapPhyPower + Str*phyReinforce + phySkillPower)*(1 + weapMastery) - phyDef) * phyBalance * skillMultiplier * phyBuff * multiplier)

Phy. Atk = [Phy. attack power + (Str stat * Phy. Reinforce)] * [1 + weapon mastery/100]

Since multiplication > addition, reinforcement is more important
/endofdiscussion

ok agreed then
/endofdiscussion
PS: btw that is what I knew and said, my buyer did not agree. Well life goes on

EDIT: why is the vote 5/5 when nobody said that 51% attack is better than 51% reinforce ????

[Ragnorak]

neither, horrible stats.

[RedBlueGreen]

neither, horrible stats.

never done this b4... but...

+1!

[Disconn3cted]

phy attack power of a weapon has more to do with its dmg than the reinforce which is not to say the reinforce doesn't matter

[LivithiuM]

Depends on your relative character level and if you are pure int/str or hybrid.

So I think the answer depends on your character more than a general one is better than the other.

[Toshiharu]

Either one. They'll end up meeting the rondo.