Page 1 of 1
attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 1:44 am
by HDEV
Hello, I want to buy a glaive and I found exactly 2 identical glaives, but one glavie with phy attack 61% and att. rating 22%(198), the other glavie with phy attack 42% and att. rating 62%(254) ... others stats and blues are exactly same, which glaive should I choose?
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 1:49 am
by ImmortalKiller
Post your int / str, the weapon's respective damage and reinforcement ranges, and then it will be much easier to tell you. What seemed like enough data to you is insufficient for anyone willing to give an answer with 100% certainty.
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 1:52 am
by _Creep_
Atack rating is more important than phy and mag.
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 1:58 am
by HDEV
I'm pure str glaiver and
ImmortalKiller wrote:Post your int / str, the weapon's respective damage and reinforcement ranges, and then it will be much easier to tell you. What seemed like enough data to you is insufficient for anyone willing to give an answer with 100% certainty.
-first weapon: phy attack power 1267 ~ 1494 phy reinforce 184.9% ~ 226.0% with 62% att. rating
-second weapon: phy attack power 1279 ~ 1509 phy reinforce 184.9% ~ 226.0% with 22% att. rating
I'm pure str 90 glaive
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 2:08 am
by Azilius
_Creep_ wrote:Atack rating is more important than phy and mag.
Purely opinion.
I'd much rather go for the one with higher phy and use 10% stones on the attack rating.
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 2:10 am
by alZen
i'd pick the 1st one if not planning on doing much pimping since the phy dmg diff is not that great compared to the AR diff.
could get either planning to pimp. 62% AR is quite high, and i wouldnt plan on touching that. so depends on the % on phy dmg to make the final pick.
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 2:18 am
by Ragnorak
_Creep_ wrote:Atack rating is more important than phy and mag.
+1
from my experience is also much easier to get higher phy. then it is to increase the atk.rating
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 2:24 am
by HDEV
ok guys thanks for the help, I will go with the higher attack rating weapon because I read also that with higher att. rating I will be able hit my maxinum dmg more than the weapon with lower att. rating
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 2:37 am
by alZen
HDEV wrote:I'm pure str glaiver and
ImmortalKiller wrote:Post your int / str, the weapon's respective damage and reinforcement ranges, and then it will be much easier to tell you. What seemed like enough data to you is insufficient for anyone willing to give an answer with 100% certainty.
-first weapon: phy attack power 1267 ~ 1494 phy reinforce 184.9% ~ 226.0% with 62% att. rating
-second weapon: phy attack power 1279 ~ 1509 phy reinforce 184.9% ~ 226.0% with 22% att. rating
I'm pure str 90 glaive
lol ... your vote options and your 1st 2nd weapons mentioned above are flipped. i voted wrongly. but yeah ... 62% AR one is my choice.
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 2:55 am
by the_wicked
2'nd is better.
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 3:24 am
by BaronSengir
ar hands down
Re: attack rating in weapon?
Posted: Thu Jan 08, 2009 4:38 am
by Alterran
HDEV wrote:I'm pure str glaiver and
ImmortalKiller wrote:Post your int / str, the weapon's respective damage and reinforcement ranges, and then it will be much easier to tell you. What seemed like enough data to you is insufficient for anyone willing to give an answer with 100% certainty.
-first weapon: phy attack power 1267 ~ 1494 phy reinforce 184.9% ~ 226.0% with 62% att. rating
-second weapon: phy attack power 1279 ~ 1509 phy reinforce 184.9% ~ 226.0% with 22% att. rating
I'm pure str 90 glaive
first glaive will give more dmg over all