Can a mod please lock this potential flame war? Thanks!

[EvGa]

+1 won't fail with lucky powder

/End

This is incorrect, sir, +1 has failed for me several times w/ lucky powdar

In your rush to try +1, you don't think you could have forgot the powder? Seems to happen to people after failing several times.. "omg failed +3 5 time now!!" *insert elixers vigorously* "OMG it failed +1 wdfff". Except in their rush to try +1 they forgot the powder.

I've been playing a loooooong time and alchemy is the main attraction for me to this game. I do it, often, as in all the time, that's how I make my gold. Lots of my guildies are the same... I've been in numerous unions..etc. Never heard nor seen of an item failing +1 except when someone goes "damn it failed +1! Oh, nvm forgot powder xD". I could be wrong, but until I see video proof, Im sticking to my claims. The red stat failing +5 though..um no.

[Diaty]

+4 to 5 won't give you a red stat. +1 won't fail with lucky powder.

You are mistaken, it was +5, you tried +6. You forgot to put lucky powder and thought you did.

Steady, +6 and beyond, prevents red stat.
Immortal, +6 and beyond, prevents weapon from being destroyed.
Astral, +5 and beyond, keeps weapon from falling below +4.
Astral requires immortal.

/End

You are a absolute morron. You can fail +1 with lucky powder, you can even fail +1 when the is lucky on your weapon and you use lucky powder. Grow a pair and actually agree with the fact that you are wrong. I could make a video sometime when I am doing alchemy. But I have had many unlucky items that failed on +1 with lucky powder.

[Crumpets]

You are a absolute morron. You can fail +1 with lucky powder, you can even fail +1 when the is lucky on your weapon and you use lucky powder. Grow a pair and actually agree with the fact that you are wrong. I could make a video sometime when I am doing alchemy. But I have had many unlucky items that failed on +1 with lucky powder.

I played for .. well about 3 years ish .. alchemied since it was released .. made MANY - MANY items .. and have NEVER failed +1 with lucky powder. I have failed it when I 'thought' I dragged a powder in.


The facts were posted by EvGa a few posts back.

+4 to 5 won't give you a red stat. +1 won't fail with lucky powder.

You are mistaken, it was +5, you tried +6. You forgot to put lucky powder and thought you did.

Steady, +6 and beyond, prevents red stat.
Immortal, +6 and beyond, prevents weapon from being destroyed.
Astral, +5 and beyond, keeps weapon from falling below +4.
Astral requires immortal.

/End

[VanTokkern]

+4 to 5 won't give you a red stat. +1 won't fail with lucky powder.

You are mistaken, it was +5, you tried +6. You forgot to put lucky powder and thought you did.

Steady, +6 and beyond, prevents red stat.
Immortal, +6 and beyond, prevents weapon from being destroyed.
Astral, +5 and beyond, keeps weapon from falling below +4.
Astral requires immortal.

/End

You are a absolute morron. You can fail +1 with lucky powder, you can even fail +1 when the is lucky on your weapon and you use lucky powder. Grow a pair and actually agree with the fact that you are wrong. I could make a video sometime when I am doing alchemy. But I have had many unlucky items that failed on +1 with lucky powder.

No, you can not.. you made a mistake, simple as.. no need to deny it, noone will think you're stupid, everyone makes mistakes. And I hate to copy people's words but in my days I have done AND seen a LOT of alchemy, and I have never ever ever failed +1 with lucky powder, or got a dura reduce from +4->+5, nor have I ever seen anyone post proof that it actually can happen. You'd think that after 5 (?) years of SRO someone would have, but it hasn't happened, guess why And if you're unsure about my alchemy claims, I can show you my previous +9/+10 (both made before the extra luck from ticket was implemented, so imagine how many elixirs that took) and 100% full blue alchemy sets (yes, several) in case you don't take my word for it..

So please don't be so ignorant and take it from experienced people, it doesn't happen..

[MysticLotus]

+1 won't fail with lucky powder

/End

This is incorrect, sir, +1 has failed for me several times w/ lucky powdar

+1

+1 DOES fail with lucky powder. Very unlikely, but it does happen. I experienced the thing twice before.

[Crumpets]

+1 won't fail with lucky powder

/End

This is incorrect, sir, +1 has failed for me several times w/ lucky powdar

+1

+1 DOES fail with lucky powder. Very unlikely, but it does happen. I experienced the thing twice before.

Ok, make video evidence.


Because it does NOT.

[XMoshe]

This is incorrect, sir, +1 has failed for me several times w/ lucky powdar

+1

+1 DOES fail with lucky powder. Very unlikely, but it does happen. I experienced the thing twice before.

Ok, make video evidence.


Because it does NOT.

Because it didn't happen to you guys doesn't mean it can't happen at all.