Bow criticals data table!

A place for general discussion about Silkroad Online. Talk about the game or ask questions. Please keep threads Silkroad Online related.
User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

I was bored. GOO Excel!

These tables will be edited if:
  • I messed up somewhere. Post here if you see gaps & stupid little errors.

I will add a knockback table for 5 and 6 arrow combo tomorrow if someone posts the following, and is either 100% sure of the results, or can provide data that I myself can analzye:
  • The probability of knockback for the 5 and 6 arrow combos
  • Does the probability of knockback go up each time you level up the skill?
  • If so, by how much?




NOTE: I'm assuming that the probability of a critical = (critical value/100).

With this table, one can look up the approximate amount of criticals you will get per combo.




6 Arrow combo!

Critical 18
Spoiler!

Critical 17
Spoiler!

Critical 16
Spoiler!

Critical 15
Spoiler!

Critical 14
Spoiler!

Critical 13
Spoiler!

Critical 12
Spoiler!

Critical 11
Spoiler!

Critical 10
Spoiler!

Critical 9
Spoiler!

Critical 8
Spoiler!

Critical 7
Spoiler!

Critical 6
Spoiler!

Critical 5
Spoiler!

Critical 4
Spoiler!

Critical 3
Spoiler!

Critical 2
Spoiler!



5 Arrow combo!


Critical 18
Spoiler!

Critical 17
Spoiler!

Critical 16
Spoiler!

Critical 15
Spoiler!

Critical 14
Spoiler!

Critical 13
Spoiler!

Critical 12
Spoiler!

Critical 11
Spoiler!

Critical 10
Spoiler!

Critical 9
Spoiler!

Critical 8
Spoiler!

Critical 7
Spoiler!

Critical 6
Spoiler!

Critical 5
Spoiler!

Critical 4
Spoiler!

Critical 3
Spoiler!

Critical 2
Spoiler!



4 Arrow combo!


Critical 18
Spoiler!

Critical 17
Spoiler!

Critical 16
Spoiler!

Critical 15
Spoiler!

Critical 14
Spoiler!

Critical 13
Spoiler!

Critical 12
Spoiler!

Critical 11
Spoiler!

Critical 10
Spoiler!

Critical 9
Spoiler!

Critical 8
Spoiler!

Critical 7
Spoiler!

Critical 6
Spoiler!

Critical 5
Spoiler!

Critical 4
Spoiler!

Critical 3
Spoiler!

Critical 2
Spoiler!



3 Arrow combo!


Critical 18
Spoiler!

Critical 17
Spoiler!

Critical 16
Spoiler!

Critical 15
Spoiler!

Critical 14
Spoiler!

Critical 13
Spoiler!

Critical 12
Spoiler!

Critical 11
Spoiler!

Critical 10
Spoiler!

Critical 9
Spoiler!

Critical 8
Spoiler!

Critical 7
Spoiler!

Critical 6
Spoiler!

Critical 5
Spoiler!

Critical 4
Spoiler!

Critical 3
Spoiler!

Critical 2
Spoiler!



2 Arrow combo!


Critical 18
Spoiler!

Critical 17
Spoiler!

Critical 16
Spoiler!

Critical 15
Spoiler!

Critical 14
Spoiler!

Critical 13
Spoiler!

Critical 12
Spoiler!

Critical 11
Spoiler!

Critical 10
Spoiler!

Critical 9
Spoiler!

Critical 8
Spoiler!

Critical 7
Spoiler!

Critical 6
Spoiler!

Critical 5
Spoiler!

Critical 4
Spoiler!

Critical 3
Spoiler!

Critical 2
Spoiler!


If anyone refers to this work, in any way shape or form, refer to THIS forum and give credit where credit is due.
Last edited by ImmortalKiller on Thu Dec 25, 2008 6:47 am, edited 2 times in total.
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
Lempi
Veteran Member
Posts: 3202
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2008 3:53 pm
Location: England

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by Lempi »

It may be because its 4am, or i've just misunderstood, but im assuming the 2-18 is the critical value on the bow?

In which case, 12 is the highest crit on a bow.
Unless you are counting SoSun too, which has max of 18, but surely due to the increased stats, it would be calculated different.

Edit; just ignore me... cant think atm. :banghead:
Edit2; No, none of the combos have crit increase.
Image
Saddam✓ Osama✓ Gaddafi✓ Justin Bieber☐ Rebecca Black☐

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

Lempi wrote:It may be because its 4am, or i've just misunderstood, but im assuming the 2-18 is the critical value on the bow?

In which case, 12 is the highest crit on a bow.
Unless you are counting SoSun too, which has max of 18, but surely due to the increased stats, it would be calculated different.

Edit; just ignore me... cant think atm. :banghead:
Edit2; No, none of the combos have crit increase.

I thought about this.

Sosun 100% Critical, according to NivlaM, is 18.
Normal 0% Critical, according to NivlaM, is 2.

I wasn't going to redo a great portion of my work for something this annoying :P.


Thanks for your information about the combos!
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
Messiah
Valued Member
Posts: 397
Joined: Thu Nov 13, 2008 10:50 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Around

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by Messiah »

Awesome work dude and its useful :)

But.. you have way too much time on your hands lol :D
ImageImage

User avatar
4reaLz
Active Member
Posts: 735
Joined: Sat Feb 10, 2007 5:52 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Tibet
Contact:

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by 4reaLz »

woah
Guild: PRIDE
Server: Tibet
Build: Pure Str Glavie
Image

Image

User avatar
DotCom
Valued Member
Posts: 497
Joined: Thu Jul 20, 2006 1:44 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Alexander

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by DotCom »

ImmortalKiller wrote:
Lempi wrote:It may be because its 4am, or i've just misunderstood, but im assuming the 2-18 is the critical value on the bow?

In which case, 12 is the highest crit on a bow.
Unless you are counting SoSun too, which has max of 18, but surely due to the increased stats, it would be calculated different.

Edit; just ignore me... cant think atm. :banghead:
Edit2; No, none of the combos have crit increase.

I thought about this.

Sosun 100% Critical, according to NivlaM, is 18.
Normal 0% Critical, according to NivlaM, is 2.

I wasn't going to redo a great portion of my work for something this annoying :P.


Thanks for your information about the combos!

Back at the 80 cap compared the criticals made with a sun 64 glaive crit 12(40%) and a normal 72 glaive crit 12(80%). Both are crit 12 but i was getting more crits from the normal glaive.
Server: Alexander

-=IMPERIAL FOREVER=-

[Quit]

User avatar
AznFury
Loyal Member
Posts: 1513
Joined: Sun Jul 06, 2008 10:59 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: The Billows

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by AznFury »

nice.
Full Force Nuker Guide

Image


Come and play Jade Dynasty with me!
In USA-East The Billows, my name is AznFury. My Inductor ID is 6440043X060206013007425Z3f9d22
Copy the code when you make your first character and get lots of free stuff!

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

DotCom wrote:
ImmortalKiller wrote:
Lempi wrote:It may be because its 4am, or i've just misunderstood, but im assuming the 2-18 is the critical value on the bow?

In which case, 12 is the highest crit on a bow.
Unless you are counting SoSun too, which has max of 18, but surely due to the increased stats, it would be calculated different.

Edit; just ignore me... cant think atm. :banghead:
Edit2; No, none of the combos have crit increase.

I thought about this.

Sosun 100% Critical, according to NivlaM, is 18.
Normal 0% Critical, according to NivlaM, is 2.

I wasn't going to redo a great portion of my work for something this annoying :P.


Thanks for your information about the combos!

Back at the 80 cap compared the criticals made with a sun 64 glaive crit 12(40%) and a normal 72 glaive crit 12(80%). Both are crit 12 but i was getting more crits from the normal glaive.


If you really wanted to test if this was valid:

Take a video of you hitting 300 mangyangs with each weapon. DON'T take pauses in the video. All 300 mangyang hits must be in the same "scene".. if you get what I mean.

Upload it and I'll crunch the numbers.


++ Can I get info on the knockback?
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
Lempi
Veteran Member
Posts: 3202
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2008 3:53 pm
Location: England

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by Lempi »

ImmortalKiller wrote:++ Can I get info on the knockback?

I cant get on atm because of traffic, but my brother's char is a bowman, and im fairly sure the 5 arrow combo has an 80% knockback chance, on each arrow. Not sure abou 6 arrow.
Image
Saddam✓ Osama✓ Gaddafi✓ Justin Bieber☐ Rebecca Black☐

User avatar
NuclearSilo
Forum God
Posts: 8834
Joined: Mon Aug 21, 2006 12:00 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Age of Wushu

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by NuclearSilo »

Lempi wrote:
ImmortalKiller wrote:++ Can I get info on the knockback?

I cant get on atm because of traffic, but my brother's char is a bowman, and im fairly sure the 5 arrow combo has an 80% knockback chance, on each arrow. Not sure abou 6 arrow.

For 5 arrow, the distribution of KB is like this: 20/80/30/20/0 or smt like that, but im sure the highest is 80%
No matter what is written in the skill description ie 30% KB, in reality it's 80% KB

@Immortalkiller: how do you calculate the values?
Last edited by NuclearSilo on Sun Dec 14, 2008 6:16 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Playing Age of Wushu, dota IMBA

User avatar
Pan_Raider(`_´)
Senior Member
Posts: 4737
Joined: Fri Jul 28, 2006 11:20 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Athens

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by Pan_Raider(`_´) »

this might get sticky and land in the bow guide section if you add the prob of the othe attacks
(devil arrow, mindbow)
Image

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

NuclearSilo wrote:
Lempi wrote:
ImmortalKiller wrote:++ Can I get info on the knockback?

I cant get on atm because of traffic, but my brother's char is a bowman, and im fairly sure the 5 arrow combo has an 80% knockback chance, on each arrow. Not sure abou 6 arrow.

For 5 arrow, the distribution of KB is like this: 20/80/40/10/0 or smt like that, but im sure the highest is 80%
No matter what is written in the skill description ie 30% KB, in reality it's 80% KB

@Immortalkiller: how do you calculate the values?


Code: Select all

(N!)/(((K!)*(N-K)!))*(P^K)*((1-P)^(N-K))
N = # of arrows.
K = # of criticals.
P = Probability of critical. (A number between 0 and 1)


Expected value, or "how many per 100 combos:"
N*P*100 = Criticals per 100 combos.
N = # of arrows.
P = Probability of critical. (A number between 0 and 1)

Upon request I'll explain what that all means.






Pan_Raider(`_´) wrote:this might get sticky and land in the bow guide section if you add the prob of the othe attacks
(devil arrow, mindbow)



Isn't that kind of obvious though >.>?

Like if you have a crit 12 bow, and you use a skill increasing crit by 12, you now have a 24% chance of a critical >.>?
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
NuclearSilo
Forum God
Posts: 8834
Joined: Mon Aug 21, 2006 12:00 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Age of Wushu

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by NuclearSilo »

wait till I finish all my exams, I'll partially unlock the secret of Critical. Yeah, it's not just a % chance :)
Playing Age of Wushu, dota IMBA

User avatar
HDEV
New Member
Posts: 29
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2008 5:55 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: eVGA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by HDEV »

Well, from my experience I can say that critical % is not always correct

For example I had 2x bows first bow was C8 and second bow C11 .... I was always getting better percent to critical with the C8 bow over the C11 .. C11 is nice on paper but I'm sure there some things hidden ... Also my friend has 2x glaives one with c9 and the other c12 ... and the c9 glaive always critical more

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

HDEV wrote:Well, from my experience I can say that critical % is not always correct

For example I had 2x bows first bow was C8 and second bow C11 .... I was always getting better percent to critical with the C8 bow over the C11 .. C11 is nice on paper but I'm sure there some things hidden ... Also my friend has 2x glaives one with c9 and the other c12 ... and the c9 glaive always critical more

As I said, take a video of 300 hits, with no interruptions, with each glaive. And I'll see if you're right.


I hate people saying XXX without proof... and what I request isn't all that tough to obtain!
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
HDEV
New Member
Posts: 29
Joined: Sun Nov 30, 2008 5:55 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: eVGA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by HDEV »

ImmortalKiller wrote:
HDEV wrote:Well, from my experience I can say that critical % is not always correct

For example I had 2x bows first bow was C8 and second bow C11 .... I was always getting better percent to critical with the C8 bow over the C11 .. C11 is nice on paper but I'm sure there some things hidden ... Also my friend has 2x glaives one with c9 and the other c12 ... and the c9 glaive always critical more

As I said, take a video of 300 hits, with no interruptions, with each glaive. And I'll see if you're right.


I hate people saying XXX without proof... and what I request isn't all that tough to obtain!


I'm saying from my experience in PvP and so on.

I can't test now as I already sold all my items and I don't play anymore :)

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

HDEV wrote:
ImmortalKiller wrote:
HDEV wrote:Well, from my experience I can say that critical % is not always correct

For example I had 2x bows first bow was C8 and second bow C11 .... I was always getting better percent to critical with the C8 bow over the C11 .. C11 is nice on paper but I'm sure there some things hidden ... Also my friend has 2x glaives one with c9 and the other c12 ... and the c9 glaive always critical more

As I said, take a video of 300 hits, with no interruptions, with each glaive. And I'll see if you're right.


I hate people saying XXX without proof... and what I request isn't all that tough to obtain!


I'm saying from my experience in PvP and so on.

I can't test now as I already sold all my items and I don't play anymore :)

Killjoy.

Anyone up for the test for me?
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
Lempi
Veteran Member
Posts: 3202
Joined: Tue Oct 07, 2008 3:53 pm
Location: England

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by Lempi »

I might be able to get a video if my brother lets me use his pc.
Mine laughs at the thought of running Fraps :oops:
Image
Saddam✓ Osama✓ Gaddafi✓ Justin Bieber☐ Rebecca Black☐

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

Lempi wrote:I might be able to get a video if my brother lets me use his pc.
Mine laughs at the thought of running Fraps :oops:

Thanks.

If it's possible, could you get two bows with a crit gap of like... 4+?
This would eliminate the % chance of error by a lot.




Edit: Are you sure about those knockback values Nuclear?
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
selenne
Frequent Member
Posts: 1176
Joined: Fri Jul 04, 2008 7:51 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Olympus

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by selenne »

NuclearSilo wrote:wait till I finish all my exams, I'll partially unlock the secret of Critical. Yeah, it's not just a % chance :)



relevant to my interests.


ot: gj immortal
Looking for the perfect MMORPG.




While i don't find:
VINDICTUS - Kalkin - lvl 30 Lann - West Server

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

selenne wrote:
NuclearSilo wrote:wait till I finish all my exams, I'll partially unlock the secret of Critical. Yeah, it's not just a % chance :)



relevant to my interests.


ot: gj immortal

And yet nuclear hasn't posted it yet >.>


& Thanks... I'm just waiting for someone to give me definitive data.
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
NuclearSilo
Forum God
Posts: 8834
Joined: Mon Aug 21, 2006 12:00 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Age of Wushu

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by NuclearSilo »

It's better to put all the data in an Excel file than put them in the spoilers
Playing Age of Wushu, dota IMBA

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

NuclearSilo wrote:It's better to put all the data in an Excel file than put them in the spoilers

It is in an excel file, but excel isn't as popular as it is useful.

I think you just want the excel file :P
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
NuclearSilo
Forum God
Posts: 8834
Joined: Mon Aug 21, 2006 12:00 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Age of Wushu

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by NuclearSilo »

well, if I were you, I'd post a SS of the Excel. Posting 50 spoilers consumes too much time
Playing Age of Wushu, dota IMBA

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

NuclearSilo wrote:well, if I were you, I'd post a SS of the Excel. Posting 50 spoilers consumes too much time


Well you still haven't posted that secret so rawr!
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

I'm going to go so far as to bump this up merely to request for the secret of criticals--

"it's not just a % chance."

I'm sitting here like this:
Image
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
BuDo
Senior Member
Posts: 4714
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2008 6:16 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Xian

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by BuDo »

It used to be the notion that the crit value on the weapons determines how high the crit damage is. But that is hard to ascertain since damages fall anywhere between a set range(Hi~Low). From my experience I found that when I use a bow with a higher crit value I tend to crit more often. And thats from observing all attacks. Not just arrow combos.

Why did you try to find out how many crits are there in those combos? Seems kinda pointless (Even tho your work is impressive). A crit on a single arrow (or 2) out of the many in a combo doesn't do much. I think players would want to know how often they can expect crits so they can time the expected occurrence of a crit with one of their big attacks.. Like strong bow vision etc.
Image

_________________________________________________
BOW Full STR Fire level 102 -- ON A LONG BREAK..POSSIBLY FOREVER

User avatar
ImmortalKiller
Active Member
Posts: 675
Joined: Thu Aug 28, 2008 2:13 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: VA/CA

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by ImmortalKiller »

BuDo wrote:It used to be the notion that the crit value on the weapons determines how high the crit damage is. But that is hard to ascertain since damages fall anywhere between a set range(Hi~Low). From my experience I found that when I use a bow with a higher crit value I tend to crit more often. And thats from observing all attacks. Not just arrow combos.

Why did you try to find out how many crits are there in those combos? Seems kinda pointless (Even tho your work is impressive). A crit on a single arrow (or 2) out of the many in a combo doesn't do much. I think players would want to know how often they can expect crits so they can time the expected occurrence of a crit with one of their big attacks.. Like strong bow vision etc.

You misinterpreted what I wrote.

I know that as the crit value on a weapon increases, the probability of a critical occurring increases. (Kinda common sense at this point in the game...)

It's fun to know how many criticals per arrow combo should be expected. This does just that. Every other skill has, from the data I've got,

Critical value on weapon + Critical added by skill) percent of critical.

I'm just hoping that a specific someone can enlighten me, as "they" said it's not just a % chance.
Counter Strike... | Source
CAL...................................................................... | Main
Silkroad Online | Aege
...................................................................................................Image

User avatar
BuDo
Senior Member
Posts: 4714
Joined: Wed Dec 24, 2008 6:16 am
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Xian

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by BuDo »

ImmortalKiller wrote:You misinterpreted what I wrote.

I know that as the crit value on a weapon increases, the probability of a critical occurring increases. (Kinda common sense at this point in the game...)

It's fun to know how many criticals per arrow combo should be expected. This does just that. Every other skill has, from the data I've got,

Critical value on weapon + Critical added by skill) percent of critical.

I'm just hoping that a specific someone can enlighten me, as "they" said it's not just a % chance.



See...this is my point. Why is it important to know when the crit damage (when it happens) is on a single arrow in the 3/4/5 arrow combo? Each arrow damage from a combo pales in comparison to the other big attacks...which is where all us bow types would rather see a crit. But never mind...its ok...You did after all say "it's fun to know". Whether I think its fun or not isn't important.. keep at your quest.
Image

_________________________________________________
BOW Full STR Fire level 102 -- ON A LONG BREAK..POSSIBLY FOREVER

User avatar
caseyd4
Active Member
Posts: 669
Joined: Fri Apr 13, 2007 5:01 pm
Quick Reply: Yes
Location: Phoenix

Re: Bow criticals data table!

Post by caseyd4 »

I agree and an even easier test to prove that criticals are more frequent depending on external factors. Try an imbue test at same levels all three Imbues. You will be very suprised at the results. Devil Bow works best. I did 100 of Each, as first hit on Snake dudes.... Btw I also Beieve Light decresese PR before it hits ;) take that into concideration Silo :P
Image

Post Reply

Return to “Silkroad General Discussion”