Thread Of The Week?

[StealMySoda]

Simple Really. Vote whether or not you would be interested in a Thread of the week?

Not saying it will happen for sure, but, just want some general feedback.

My Sketch Idea of how we could do it.
-5 Top threads are picked, probably by a mod, and in this case, probably zypher as this is his section
-People vote on a poll, and the top thread is stickied for the week. With a history of past top threads underneath it.
-Only offtopic threads would be eligible

Yes? No? Maybe? Vote Away.

If you vote, please explain why

[Th3souL]

i voted yes, i think it would encorage people to put that extra effort into their threads rather than half a**ed efforts.

[RuYi]

i voted yes, i think it would encorage people to put that extra effort into there threads rather than half a**ed efforts.

I wasn't sure at first, but Mr. Soul here has a point, so if it can improve things, give it a try I'd say.

[Wu]

hm on side it sounds like a good idea

keeping focus on a few outstanding topics, might light up the section some more

then again.. honestly.. Im not sure if it is necessary, good threads don't die very quick anyway, as long as people dont start sh~t

and people still go off topic to soon and then the topic dies anyway.

Im not sure if stickying a thread would encourage people to move back on topic.. or if the topics would just lay to waste

if this will be implemented I just dont hope people start their flame sh~t there too >.>

all this coming from a person with a few months of somewhat active SRF contribution


vote? yes. give it a try, see how it goes

[dom]

Only if I can be forum member of the year.

[Locketart]

I have a feeling this thread of the week thing will only encourage people to make more idiotic threads.

[Nuklear]

Let's not forget this was my idea.
Credit where credit is due.
I don't see any negatives to this notion so let's get this ball rolling.

[dom]

Let's not forget this was my idea.
Credit where credit is due.
I don't see any negatives to this notion so let's get this ball rolling.

Read the post above yours.


I can see it now...

"omg i'm depressed and broke, but it's not the drugs"

"LOL LOOK AT DIS ViDEO YOS LAWL TIS SO FUNNEH lololol1!!!1121"

"[Poll] DON'T CLICK ME LOLLll: How big is your penis?"

[deep.in]

I have a feeling this thread of the week thing will only encourage people to make more idiotic threads.

I agree. There will be flames in the possibly "opponents" threads, like - omg, onother gay thread and ect. BUT it's a very good idea...and we simply can try it out, because...do we lose anything if we risk? No

So...yes

PS. Who takes the risk, drinks shampagne later:D

[Th3souL]

I have a feeling this thread of the week thing will only encourage people to make more idiotic threads.

I disagree, I cant see the logic in people making idiotic threads to obtain thread of the week. That just doesnt make sence.

Sure you'll still have these people starting pointless threads but i cant see how this would increase the number of these.

[dom]

...do we lose anything if we do?

Yes. Our honour.

[BlackFox]

Read the post above yours.


I can see it now...

"omg i'm depressed and broke, but it's not the drugs"

"LOL LOOK AT DIS ViDEO YOS LAWL TIS SO FUNNEH lololol1!!!1121"

"[Poll] DON'T CLICK ME LOLLll: How big is your penis?"

well lol I dont think "How big is your penis" be award wining thread

Well Good idea anyway . To try it dont hurt . only is not about ..... M*

[ghostkilla43]

i think this could work against us people are gonna want to have their thread to be the thread of the week and this =spam spam spam...

[StealMySoda]

You've all made some good points.

I have to say I'm now leaning more towards not having it

Keep em' coming.

[ghostkilla43]

sweet^^

[Itonami]

Well there would be more stupid threads of course but I think there would be a few good threads worth making thread of the week. Don't really set rules for the kind of thread that would be eligible, other than not complete spam-ish retardedness. You know what I mean.

I think it's a good idea

Is it possible to change my vote to the 'Yes, but for the entire forum' option? lol

[Draquish]

It would encourage people to make interesting threads, I say yes.

[Luoma]

i like the idea, hope to see it soon

[Hellzowner]

I voted yes because it would be good to have popular threads stickyed for a bit to show what other people have to say n' stuff

[Ashikiheyun]

I voted yes, sounds like a fun thing to do!

[Bai]

Ooohh..hell yes~!!

[_Banned]

Heres an idea Click

[fena]

Heres an idea Click

Something terrible must have happened to that man as a child...

On-Topic: I say yes, primarily for the reason that I believe WE, as in we normal Forum users should have an opportunity for our own threads to be stickied. Not just the occasional announcement about how Spam Games are banned. Something a little more interesting. Maybe news about how a two-hundred foot dog was discovered living in a igloo in Antarctica.
It's time for some interesting threads to get stickied.

Besides, I can't see any downsides to this. Why would people make "idiotic threads" in response to this? People that do that aren't the kind of people we want around these Forums anyways.

My opinion, is all.

[Reise]

Thread of the week? Be prepared for a level of idiocy not yet witnessed before on a forum then. The attention whoring and thread spam will go far beyond what we have now. People will do it MORE so they can be in the running for thread of the week.

[Stress]

It might improve the general quality of the posts, BUT it might decrease it. I cannot asses the effects of having something like this.

In the first place, it could lead people into posting good, valuable stuff. This is the desired effect.

On the other hand, it can create tons of spam as well as attention whoring threads.


Every coin has two sides, Soda. Flip the coin and see which side comes out on top.

[Nuklear]

I believe the thinking that it will hurt the forum is a flawed one. Mostly likely the TotW will either be determined by a mod or be majority consensus. A mod is not going to pick a shit thread and neither will the majority of the people (having faith in the forum here). So naturally people will know that shit threads aren't going to publicized besides the flamming that goes on w/in them. There might be an initial pickup of crap from once this starts but I think we will see the same or less than as we do now.

[ranger4life]

is this to insult me? cuz in my thread u all were making fun of me...but once i trake thos pics we will see

mwahahahahahahaha

[Nuklear]

Hopefully we'll see a decrease of those wonderful posts as demonstrated above by ranger.

[ranger4life]

Hopefully we'll see a decrease of those wonderful posts as demonstrated above by ranger.

**** you

[Nuklear]

Another great demonstration.