Page 1 of 1
All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 1:53 am
by BuDo
Well I did buy a laptop 2 months ago and it was great for gaming. But I returned it because (1) It wasn't' really the laptop that I was looking for and (2) I became curious about all in one PCs...
I hate clutter and love open spaces. Because of that I haven't owned a traditional desktop tower since 2008.....Frankly I think PC towers are going to be a thing of the past soon because of the trend towards smaller, lighter, thinner and more powerful
What I want to know from you guys is if All-in-one PCs are good enough for all sorts of gaming as well as 3D and 2D modeling softwares like AutoCAD... I don't mind the reduced mobility anymore... Thanks.
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 2:34 am
by Azilius
Find specs, google if specs are good enough for games you want or specific cad software. That's all there is to it.
Making your own desktop IS and will be the cheapest and most cost efficient solution for a long time though.
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 5:45 am
by Toshiharu
Problem with all in one PCs is that it's pretty much a slightly pricier laptop. Unless you want it to be mobile then just stick to a laptop. If you really don't care build your PC. I know everybody is afraid to do so, but it's not hard.
Beyond that what kind of games do you play? How fast do you want things to render? That's really the main question here. It can determine a huge price difference.. well "fast" in rendering is vague lol.
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 6:18 am
by Avalanche
My dad has one, the HP one that is touchscreen. IMO its not that impressive but the lack of having a physical tower is nice.
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 6:39 am
by BuDo
Toshiharu wrote:Problem with all in one PCs is that it's pretty much a slightly pricier laptop. Unless you want it to be mobile then just stick to a laptop. If you really don't care build your PC. I know everybody is afraid to do so, but it's not hard.
Beyond that what kind of games do you play? How fast do you want things to render? That's really the main question here. It can determine a huge price difference.. well "fast" in rendering is vague lol.
Oh got no problem building my own PC but I just cant be bothered with them anymore....They just become noisy dust collectors in the end with a rats nest of wires behind them....I play FPS games as well as MMORPGs mostly... I was hoping to hear from experience regarding the All-in-ones...
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 6:41 am
by BuDo
Avalanche wrote:My dad has one, the HP one that is touchscreen. IMO its not that impressive but the lack of having a physical tower is nice.
Ya I hate anything HP...and that touch screen feature is just dumb redundancy...
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 6:56 am
by Toshiharu
BuDo wrote:They just become noisy dust collectors in the end with a rats nest of wires behind them....I play FPS games as well as MMORPGs mostly
Fair enough. Though you have to be more specific on what games. It can mean quite a bit of a difference. Though noisy? Most video cards and CPU heatsinks have become far quieter over the past years. I'm surprised actually.
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 7:05 am
by BuDo
LOLOLOLOL............ "JUST ONE GOD DAM PERIOD FOR CHRIST SAKES"......LOLOLOLOL... I haven't laugh that hard in a while... Anywho I play Tera online.. And will probably play Guild wars 2..... And just about FPS you can think of for the PC... Nothing old... All new games.....
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 7:20 am
by Toshiharu
You're a homosexual for using all those periods without a use. Such an awful style of typing? Is it a style? Well whatever.
Tera and GW2 would probably do fine with something midrange. Just a quick search and midrange brings up around this price range.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.a ... 6883220168Problem is like I said it's a laptop basically, but priced a bit more. Honestly that isn't even worth the price. Also the intended audience is clearly not for gamers.
I suggest staying away from all in ones.
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 5:12 pm
by BuDo
Toshiharu wrote:You're a homosexual for using all those periods without a use. Such an awful style of typing? Is it a style? Well whatever.
Tera and GW2 would probably do fine with something midrange. Just a quick search and midrange brings up around this price range.
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.a ... 6883220168Problem is like I said it's a laptop basically, but priced a bit more. Honestly that isn't even worth the price. Also the intended audience is clearly not for gamers.
I suggest staying away from all in ones.
Hmmm..... You may have a point about these all-in-one PCs.... They're not there yet when it comes to gaming.... The current ones on the market are not targeted at gaming as you said.... I should probably hold off buying one right now for fear of looking like a homosexual... Or I might just get one still seeing as I like to explore possibilities.... Anyways... Thanks for your input.. It was both helpful (honestly) and funny.. 
and I find value in that..... Seriously again I thank you..
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 9:11 pm
by *BlackFox
What is the difference between "All-In-One PCs" and a regular PC?
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Sun Sep 30, 2012 9:41 pm
by poehalcho
*BlackFox wrote:What is the difference between "All-In-One PCs" and a regular PC?
-Touchscreen
-everything is packed inside the monitor.
it's a essentially a notebook on a standard. Though prefer to call it an marketing scam :/. It thrives entirely on the fact that it's flashy and new. Touchscreen? have fun cleaning it after a week. And the size obviously limits the components power or at the very least makes it more prone to overheating. And unlike a laptop which features the same downsides it's not mobile so as to make up for it.
Tower PC desktops are still the way to go. Newer != better. Anyone who thinks otherwise should just burn
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 10:16 am
by woutR
Toshiharu wrote:You're a homosexual for using all those periods without a use.
lold
OT: My grandpa has the HP one. I don't think it looks that much better than a regular desktop/laptop, it's very very heavy (like truckload heavy) and it's definitely not suitable for gaming.
My grandpa is so afraid of scratches on the screen he's using some kind of improvised 'finger' made out of a straw and some viscose cloth. He honestly looked much more happy with just a laptop.
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 1:53 pm
by Majorharper
My uncle has one in his kitchen, they use it for recipes and other cooking stuff, and casual browsing when into a heavy discussion about stuff. Yet it is the only use for it. He has one ultrabook, an alien aware laptop, a dell xps laptop, a computer tower e.t.c.
Bit of an overkill hahahaha. The average computer per person ratio in their house is 3:1 hahahaha
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 4:10 pm
by *BlackFox
poehalcho wrote:-Touchscreen
-everything is packed inside the monitor.
it's a essentially a notebook on a standard. Though prefer to call it an marketing scam :/. It thrives entirely on the fact that it's flashy and new. Touchscreen? have fun cleaning it after a week. And the size obviously limits the components power or at the very least makes it more prone to overheating. And unlike a laptop which features the same downsides it's not mobile so as to make up for it.
Tower PC desktops are still the way to go. Newer != better. Anyone who thinks otherwise should just burn
Ah okay.. thank you for the info. Well.. I certainly wouldn't buy it, that's for sure!
Re: All in one PCs....Are they good enough?
Posted: Mon Oct 01, 2012 6:53 pm
by Vaya
Nothing beats a good ol' tower PC.