Silkroad Online Forums

comment,criticsm and also rate thx

Me like is a 9/10 if you me ask

Yay for no floating heads!

Anyway, the part at her back is very messy, while the part on her front is clean(er). It somehow just doesn't fit.
I don't really know what to think of this one, sorry :/

Edit; If I'd go pure for looks, I'd probably give it a 6.5/10.

Looks great, 8,5 / 10

its actually wonderfull, ++

9/10, the right side is great

7.5-8/10 Text/Balance issues.

She's hot

7.5/10

thx at least now I made a rocking new sig better than my other ones

Yes! Finally i get to criticize you again JC!

As far as i know this still doesn't beat your sudden and best sig you've made the Rouge one. Colors! I'll wait for someone to say that it looks like a milk shake gone wrong. Try making monochrome sigs, it might teach you something.

Let's count the colors! 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12. Wow! Your sigs are more hectic than mine!

Nice try...3/5
In our former C.L teachers words, R.S!
These are all jokes...
But seriously 3/5! JC you can do better, if got 50/50 in math you can make kick ass sigz.


*sigh*

LM wrote:Yes! Finally i get to criticize you again JC!

As far as i know this still doesn't beat your sudden and best sig you've made the Rouge one. Colors! I'll wait for someone to say that it looks like a milk shake gone wrong. Try making monochrome sigs, it might teach you something.

Let's count the colors! 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9,10,11,12. Wow! Your sigs are more hectic than mine!

Nice try...3/5
In our former C.L teachers words, R.S!
These are all jokes...
But seriously 3/5! JC you can do better, if got 50/50 in math you can make kick ass sigz.


*sigh*

Dude there're more colors in YOUR sig and in HIS.. than 12..

Twelve, COLOURS not shades of one colour.

Snudge wrote:Twelve, COLOURS not shades of one colour.

*Sigh* imho that's just DIFFERENT COLORS.. your monitor displays more than 6.5m colors.. they all are different colors to me..

Whoa, that's a flurry of colors. IMHO, it reminds me of that "strawberry-kiwi puke" comment from Rizla lol.

Try matching colors/ colros that work well together. Text and balance needs fixing. I also find the left and right too messy. The smudging on the right looks random.

Nice work though. 7.5/10

Only due to further analization, not because of anyone else's comments have I decided to lower my rating on this slightly, Only by .5 points on each end, to 7.0-7.5/10. I am thrown off by some of the elements in the right side of the signature, disrubtping the overall flow of the image, not to mention it is HEAVILY unbalanced to the left side, so once we finally manage to get our eyes over the left side effects, then over the focal, we are derailed.

I guess I would kind of relate it to one of those perpetual motion devices that had the weights all screwy so it only bobs for like 20 seconds and stops, whereas it should go on for an inordinate amount of time.