NLPR - A New World
Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 6:04 pm
but nice concept
Silkroad Online Forums
Free Forums for Silkroad Online players.
https://dev.silkroadforums.com/
NLPR - A New World
Page 1 of 1
Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 6:09 pm
lightsource a bit too vague imo..
but nice concept
but nice concept
Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 6:29 pm
cin - master of lightsource
Every sig he's critical about it XD
Every sig he's critical about it XD
Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 6:31 pm
dom wrote:cin - master of lightsource
Every sig he's critical about it XD
hehe
well but in most sigs its like this low opacity big white brush thing oO
cant help it just dont look like real light on most
Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 7:05 pm
pretty nice ^^ maby the c4d looks abit out of place, but the rest i love 
8.5/10
8.5/10
Posted: Mon Sep 17, 2007 9:08 pm
Very cool idea, but plagued with continuity/scale errors.
Shadow underneath c4d shouldn't be entirely crisp, it would blur out according to distance from the ground, so the right side of the shadow would be sharp, but progressively blurry towards the left.
The way the shadow on the c4d is being projected it has a single light source directly or nearly directly above it, which would mean the fishes shadow would be closer to us, or further down depending on how you look at it. Also due to that the fishes shadow wouldnt touch the platform.
The platform the people (I think its people) are walking on seems very pasted in to me, and it doesnt look like its scaling down enough to imply distance considering close to us are these giant fish. Proportionally it doesnt seem to fit.
Uber lightsource doesnt match your shadows and an alien ufo has just finished beaming up a cow from the pasture. (hehe j/k, upper left corner)
As always, with sincere respect and
Shadow underneath c4d shouldn't be entirely crisp, it would blur out according to distance from the ground, so the right side of the shadow would be sharp, but progressively blurry towards the left.
The way the shadow on the c4d is being projected it has a single light source directly or nearly directly above it, which would mean the fishes shadow would be closer to us, or further down depending on how you look at it. Also due to that the fishes shadow wouldnt touch the platform.
The platform the people (I think its people) are walking on seems very pasted in to me, and it doesnt look like its scaling down enough to imply distance considering close to us are these giant fish. Proportionally it doesnt seem to fit.
Uber lightsource doesnt match your shadows and an alien ufo has just finished beaming up a cow from the pasture. (hehe j/k, upper left corner)
As always, with sincere respect and
Posted: Tue Sep 18, 2007 12:22 am
Mellow and bright lights don't work well together XD
Posted: Tue Sep 18, 2007 1:15 am
Shadowman20818 wrote:Mellow and bright lights don't work well together XD
*slaps shadowman* YES THEY DO
You showed me this the other day
+1 the c4d looks a bit out of place
Posted: Tue Sep 18, 2007 2:50 am
i like the 3dness of it all
Posted: Tue Sep 18, 2007 5:54 am
I like it. It made me think something like, "If Salvador Dali had PS, he'd have made that." lol I kinda liked the contrast of the sharp C4D and the softness of the rest of the image.
Posted: Tue Sep 18, 2007 1:20 pm
Rizla wrote:Very cool idea, but plagued with continuity/scale errors.
Shadow underneath c4d shouldn't be entirely crisp, it would blur out according to distance from the ground, so the right side of the shadow would be sharp, but progressively blurry towards the left.
The way the shadow on the c4d is being projected it has a single light source directly or nearly directly above it, which would mean the fishes shadow would be closer to us, or further down depending on how you look at it. Also due to that the fishes shadow wouldnt touch the platform.
The platform the people (I think its people) are walking on seems very pasted in to me, and it doesnt look like its scaling down enough to imply distance considering close to us are these giant fish. Proportionally it doesnt seem to fit.
Uber lightsource doesnt match your shadows and an alien ufo has just finished beaming up a cow from the pasture. (hehe j/k, upper left corner)
As always, with sincere respect and
Thanks Riz, im not done with it yet still working on light and shadows.
And the blue part in the upper left corner must be a c4d gone wrong.