Silkroad Online Forums

V2:


CnC

I think these planets really unfitting. Expect the one on his right shoulder they all look out of place. I prefer the C4D more gj on it

i like the 2nd one but overall, 6.5/10. I don't really like the sig. Planets are just BOO.

I was supposed to recreate the things where his eyes are, but I failed and switched to planets

I don't get why people are knocking the planet things. It was the first thing I noticed and I think it gives the sig a unique feeling. I think it would cooler with some color though. :}

I like the planets. It looks really nice. No C4D version for me. They look just too random.

No c4d, sersly. Dont listen to kirk. :p

Don't mind kirk, he had to post in yet another rubbish way.

I think the planets make the whole thing unique, and are very fitting to the theme/name you gave the sig.

Yet the sig is in black and white. Which i know is kind off a trend here, but shouldn't always be followed.

I don't know, the sig makes me invision bits of purple, etc. You need color man.

The stock was originally b&w



I tried coloring it early on, but I failed. So, I just kept going b&w.

Fools! C4D version is the shiz.

Now that I've seen the stock not as impressed. It had a lot more potential you could have leeched out.

Here's my problem with the planet's they're done well and they blend with the piece but I don't feel they blend in with the atmosphere. If it wasn't for the topic title I would have never guessed what your reasoning behind the "balls" were. That being said you could have added a more space like feel if you wanted to portray planets. Right now with that more teal colour scheme you have going it feels "under watering" to me with the planets being air bubbles.

Anyways, good lighting try blurring and re-burning the edges the planet infront of him for added sense of depth. Other then that good job. Good job with the canvas size too.....so many people always stick to one size without really considering the stock but I feel the slim canvas worked real well with this.

V2:


I guess I need to put some text, I can't think of what though.

I tihnk you should make a gradient with the colours of the 2 versions.